The trouble with Nicholas Nalli’s paper on “Gunshot-wound dynamics model’ for JFK assassination

ZAPRUDER

This paper, published in the scientific journal Heliyon, represents an attempt to salvage Professor Luis Alvarez’s model of the gunshot that killed President Kennedy. Alvarez tried to explain the rearward recoil motion of Kennedy’s head, seen in Abraham Zapruder’s film, by what he called a “jetting effect.”

Alvarez experimented by firing bullets into a large class of objects. In all cases but one, photographs showed that a bullet hitting a semi-hard object filled with fluid drove object away from the source of the bullet. Only in the case of melons did Avarez see the desired rearward “jetting effect.” So he ignored the evidence he didn’t like and touted the evidence he did. Sadly for his model, human heads are very different from melons.

Head ShotThe paper proceeds from a key false assumption. This is that the small movement forward of Kennedy’s head (from Zapruder frames Z312 to Z313) is due to the impact of a bullet from the rear.  However, a careful  viewing of the film reveals that the limousine slows dramatically and comes to a virtual or almost complete stop just prior to the impact of the bullet in frame Z313.  It is this deceleration of the limousine that causes a wounded listless Kennedy to continue moving forward relative to the decelerating vehicle and the other unwounded people in the vehicle who are stabilized by their musculature.

Any theory in science, no matter how sophisticated, involved, or advanced must ultimately be tested in the crucible of empiricism.  Any theory that is not consistent with experimental results is quickly discarded.  Any model for the assassination involving a Mannlicher-Carcanno (.26 cal) round impacting Kennedy’s head from behind must address the problem that a round hitting in the middle rear of the skull, as determined by the Warren Commission, would come out his forehead or eye socket as proven in multiple tests conducted by Dr. Alfred Olivier at the Army Ballistics Lab in Aberdeen Maryland, a feature that was not observed.

This predicament caused the House Select Committee on Assassinations to conjecture that the round actually strikes the top right part of Kennedy’s head from the rear and passes through, the last conceivable refuge for the model.   This scenario has two problems.

JFK motorcadeFirst, it’s not consistent with the head wound images on the Zapruder film.  Second, the Discovery channel performed just such a live-fire test using a Mannlicher-Carcanno rifle and an anthropomorphic dummy to represent Kennedy (Inside the Target Car -2008).  The documentary made a point of indicating fragments and debris were driven forward towards the front of the limousine, but there was NO HEAD RECOIL BACKWARDS due to jetting or any other effect.

Nobel Laureate Richard Feynman was fond of saying that “If it disagrees with experiment, it’s wrong.” In that simple statement is the key to science. It doesn’t make any difference how beautiful your guess is, it doesn’t make any difference how smart you are, who made the guess, or what his name is. If it disagrees with experiment, it’s wrong. That’s all there is to it.”

Rush to the knoll

After the gunfire spectators rushed to the grassy knoll where they thought shots had come.

In Nalli’s case, it doesn’t matter how many variables he calculates or considers, or how many computer simulations he runs, because his model doesn’t agree with experiments, it’s wrong.    It isn’t necessary to check his extensive mathematics or analysis because his conclusions are inconsistent with experiments already performed.  Case closed.

 

In fact, the most direct and straightforward explanation for the rearward motion of Kennedy’s head exhibited in the Zapruder film is that it was simply struck by a projectile from the front right side that remained inside his head causing it to recoil backwards, precisely in the manner of an inverted ballistic pendulum.

Nalli actually mentions the ballistic pendulum multiple times in his paper but somehow fails to make this simple connection, arguing that this scenario for Kennedy  is “physically ruled out,” a conclusion that bears no more relationship to reality than the rest of his paper.

When a ballistic pendulum is struck by a bullet that remains inside the wooden block, it causes the pendulum to recoil back and upwards, the height providing an indication of the initial velocity of the bullet. This is precisely what would happen to Kennedy’s head (in an inverted fashion), if he were struck by a bullet from the front side, which remained inside his head causing it to absorb the recoil momentum of the round and react backwards and to the left.  This would happen if he were struck by a small caliber, (~.22) high speed frangible round.

This is not only the most plausible and straightforward explanation but is also the only explanation consistent with both the laws of physics and the film record.

A Test

This suggests a very simple test.  While the Discovery channel performed such a test firing a large (.30 cal) rifle at the head of an anthropomorphic dummy from the right front side from the actual Grassy Knoll (Inside the Target Car), the high caliber round just punched through the dummy’s head.

However, a small caliber frangible round would remain inside, the dummy’s head would recoil, and the Zapruder film would be readily matched up.   While anthropomorphic dummies and high speed camera’s are not cheap, they are well within the budgets of many technically oriented cable television programs currently in production.

It is indeed striking that after 55 years of documentaries, simulations, and staged reenactments devoted to the Kennedy assassination, not a single one has ever performed this one simple test, motivated by the well-known ballistic pendulum.  This  inexplicable omission, in and of itself, speaks volumes.

6 comments

  1. Randy Robertson says:

    Both Chambers and Nalli are wrong. The first bullet came from behind, entered where the autopsy doctors identified an entry wound, fragmented and a fragment went forward and cracked the inner surface of the windshield causing a flare of reflected sunlight on frame 314 as the windshield was deformed from the impact. This proves beyond a doubt that the first bullet DID NOT come from the front. This explosive exit wound was confined to the anterior portion of the right parietal bone and ejected the Weitzman and Harper skull fragments into Dealey Plaza as well as two smaller skull fragments down into the limo. The top rear of the head is undisturbed which would not be the case if the first shot came from the front. A second shot to the head from the front struck the top rear of the head, pushing the head rearward and ejected the Delta skull fragment, bearing a portion of an exit wound onto the trunk of the limo where it was retrieved by Jackie and later taken to the autopsy room where it was x-rayed and examined. The forward and backward movements of the head and the initial ejection of four skull fragments is well documented in the CBS News/Itek study.

    Nalli is wrong because there is evidence for two gunshot wounds to the head by virtue of intersecting fracture lines, Puppe’s Law, being present on the authentic postmortem skull radiographs. An paper describing these findings passed peer review by the Journal of Forensic Science but they declined to publish it, despite having passed peer review because it might initiate ” discussion”. A single shot from behind will not cause the forward and backward movement of the head and can’t cause the delayed rearward ejection of a large piece of skull from the top rear of JFK’s head. The flare of reflected light from the windshield cracking at 314 proves that Chambers is wrong about a single shot from the front.

  2. Randy Owen says:

    The PBS show “Nova: Who Shot President Kennedy?” in 1988 showed a very brief film clip of the Alvarez’ experiment. The reinforced melon does move backward toward the shooter, who is off-camera. BUT, not mentioned in the show while clearly evident, is that the step ladder the melon was resting on moves forward!

  3. I believe the discussions involve the transfer of momentum from a projectile to a target. If the target, in this case a human head, is dense enough to absorb significant amounts of momentum it will have the absorbed momentum proportionally transferred in the direction of the projectile. If, like the the dummy of Inside The Target Car, the head does not have adequate density to absorb significant portions of the projectile’s momentum then it will not display significant transfer of momentum. A bullet does not have to remain inside the skull to cause the skull to move in the direction of the bullet. 99% of the bullet’s momentum can be absorbed and the bullet will still pass through the skull. Similarly, 1% of the bullet’s momentum can be absorbed, but the observable transfer of momentum will approach being negligible. I do not know what happened, but I have trouble seeing Jackie lurch forward at 313. I also am aware of windshield and chrome strip damage and it came from somewhere at some time. Then there is the damage in the right rear area of Kennedy’s head as described by McClellan, Crenshaw and others. I tend to sense this damage is the result of the momentum of a projectile.

  4. Eddy says:

    “In examining this, three separate dynamical phenomena will be considered in Section 2 that explain behaviors observed in the Zapruder Film@ – Nalli

    “the most direct and straightforward explanation for the rearward motion of Kennedy’s head exhibited in the Zapruder film is that it was simply struck by a projectile” – Chambers

    Both using the same dangerous assumption. Which is ; the extant Zapruder film accurately reflects the events of the assassination. That may be true, but is a horribly fragile assumption to base a theory on.

  5. Rick G. says:

    I believe “Enemy of the Truth,” by Sherry Feister, one of the country’s foremost forensic experts on gunshot wounds and the resulting blood spatter is one of the best and most sensible analyses of what is seen in the Z Film. It is certainly more worthy than Alvarez’s theory or Nalli’s paper.

  6. H Beazley says:

    Read the 5 volume report from Douglas Horne of the ARRB that explains that JFK was killed by two shots from the front. This view was and is supported by Dr. Charles Crenshaw and Dr. David Mantik years ago. The name of this site is JFKFACTS and has an obligation to report them.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

In seeking to expand the range of informed debate about the events of 1963 and its aftermath, JFKFacts.org welcomes comments that are factual, engaging, and civil. more

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

exam: Passeasy 9L0-006 Test Questions With High Quality, Recenty Updated DMDI201 Answers UP To 50% Off, Provide Discount SG1-001 Test Online Sale, Useful E20-351 Test Prep Online, Pass4sure E20-855 Practice Exam Questions With Low Price, 100% Pass Guaranteed or Full Refund E22-258 Self Study Latest Version PDF&VCE, Sale Latest GPEN Exam Paper 100% Pass With A High Score, Pass4sure GG0-300 Vce Software Guaranteed Success, High Pass Rate HP0-803 Exam Collection with PDF and VCE Engine, 100% Pass HP0-207 Book With Accurate Answers, Exambible ACSO-PRACTICE-01 Questions Is Your Best Choice, Help To Pass HP0-S29 Real Exam With Accurate Answers, Helpful 000-748 Training with PDF and VCE Engine, 50% OFF A2090-614 Training Guide With New Discount, New Release A4040-122 Brain Dumps On Store, Certshared P6040-026 Dump Test Is What You Need To Take, Buy Best ICDL-IT Pdf Download Is Your Best Choice, The Best MB4-534 Sample Questions UP To 50% Off, Free Download Real MB2-632 Test Software Is Your Best Choice, Buy Latest ITILSC-OSA Material Pdf Latest Version PDF&VCE, The Most Effective 1T6-215 Training With Low Price, Free Download Real 920-460 Practise Questions Covers All Key Points, 100% Pass Guarantee 1Z0-457 Actual Test On Store, Offer HDPCD Exam Vce Guaranteed Success, Valid and updated HP2-E32 Exam Dump Sale, Offer C90-05A Online Exam Is What You Need To Take, Most Popular 100-500 Exam Engines For Download, Passguide 190-621 Dump Test Is Updated Daily, Passeasy 8004 Braindump With 100% Pass Rate,

male enhancement: sex track on demand male enhancement does cialis make you bigger black male movie stars drugs and effects hotrod 5000 can taking viagra cause impotence dick hard penis growth pills penis enlargment review best penis enlargement literotica penis growth having a big dick libido supplements andropenis review mens pills male erect penis hot guys boners penis enlargement surgery results fish oil testosterone 6 inch thick cock the average size penis how to determine penis size s 300 pill make penis smaller penis strech andropenis extender no sex drive penis sex how big is my lot how to increase testosterone level extenze pills reviews vacuum pump for erectile dysfunction ginseng good for energy pills reviews hims ed pills gnc prolatis average penis size america penis size genetics how to get good at sex how to get a bonner big penis pictures release pills no script viagra alpha male promotions how to enlarge the penis testosterone booster amazon oh california song 2020 penis numbing e 46 pill what is the average length of a pennis sparxx rx reviews testotek for sale ed diagnosis what penis pills actually work best pills for men zyrexin gnc cock pumping pics

cbd oil: fda approved cbd oil rh baby coupons cbd oil texas legal cbd oil pets uncanna cbd cbd oil nevada cbd oil hair regrowth dan bilzerian cbd vaping cbd oil dangerous lifes balance cbd santa cruz medicinals iris gummies can you buy cbd oil blue creek cbd pain bomb translation porque advanceable technology llc can cbd oil trigger migraines relax gummies cbd infused when toonyake cbd oil 600mg cbd terpenes vs cbd oil castor oil plant picture slactavis cbd cbd oil for ocd and anxiety are cbd gummies effective cbd stroke is weed an anti inflammatory 300 rt pens male side view reference how to consume cbd oil canna complete reviews cbd and acne reddit stat script cbd for shingles frowned upon cbd houston texas hemp oil for knee pain cbd oil urine test medscape report cbd before bed why cbd oil potency matters protein kinase cbd oil vision cbd oil comes from what plant cbd oil and fatigue where to find low temperature diamonds elite dangerous fired for cbd oil cbd coupons free shipping best full spectrum cbd oil reddit dermatitis en espanol what does cbd oil do for pain liquid gold turmeric vs pure cbd oil cbd oil in a vape pen german certified cbd oil how long does cbd oil take to work in humans does baclofen interact badly with cbd oil cbd crystals how to use cbd oil get you high

weight loss: dr oz weight loss pill utah weight loss center big smo weight loss jonah hill weight loss workout james brown nfl weight loss printable weight loss journal sweet potato vs potato weight loss maintaining weight loss jason alexander weight loss stackers 3 diet pills natural weight loss drinks weight loss resorts near me glucagon weight loss how water helps weight loss venlafaxine and weight loss mid south weight loss clinic healthy fruit smoothies for weight loss which is the best diet pills potassium gluconate weight loss bulletproof weight loss best protein food for weight loss mary lambert weight loss b12 vitamins for weight loss weight loss bands how much b12 to inject for weight loss wheatgrass weight loss weight loss headache fatigue weight loss 2 weeks why is alcohol bad for weight loss new england weight loss center weight loss 30 days challenge suryanamaskar for weight loss 10 week weight loss challenge comprehensive weight loss center best mens weight loss zantrex diet pills review brandon bowen weight loss tocarra jones weight loss top weight loss pills 2019 glucomannan weight loss dosage metabo extreme weight loss diet pills total weight loss newnan ga weight loss pills detox atkins diet weight loss rate 100 natural weight loss pills perscription weight loss pills how to loose weight without diet pills magnetic toe rings for weight loss reliable diet pills ice type 1 weight loss quick weight loss secrets best indian diet plan for weight loss liquid diet foods for weight loss hidori rose weight loss fat burning vitamins dr oz weight loss diet plans evolution lean keto reviews green smoothies for weight loss

vape: kilo vape pods who died from a ecig vss vape vape pen heavy hitter green dragon vape pen what type of coils will uwell crown v2 takew easy vape 5 vaporizer theraflu vapor patch vape 22 pen vape kits ebay mercury vapor lights thc oil for vape vapor blaster for sale 20700 vape battery vicks on penis best online vape store 2016 nugget ecig smok alien problems temperature control ecig rebuild ecig coil uk ecig review 3l vapor stainless steel mesh ecig vape battery case cloud 9 vape juice review vaping debate e cigarette creation hello kitty ecig juul like products new uwell crown tank aspire breeze vs juul euphoria vapor outlet zeus tank juul pod alternative rba definition fanta vape juice top box mod vapes boiling point and vapor pressure x baby coils can drug dogs smell vape pens tfv12 mesh gta big smoke rda atomizer tank smok big baby rba best budget e juice cool vape juice smok x cube bt50 limited edition vape on amazon uwell pod leaking hercules vape tank uwell crown 2 in studies ecig forum decorated can you use max vg in a uwell crown vape exchange college park md what type of coils will uwell crown v2 takew how many deaths caused by vaping voopoo vinci mvg dotmod dotbox 75w