The new JFK files: What Politico missed about the CIA role

The GhostThe first nationally known analysts to weigh in on the new JFK files are Phil Shenon and Larry Sabato, former New York Times reporter and University of Virginia professor respectively. In a story for Politico Magazine, they purport to tell the story How the CIA Came to Doubt the Official Story of JFK’s Murder.

The tipoff to the story’s limitations is the headline, which sounds a bit odd: how the CIA came to doubt the official story…

The CIA was the source for key parts of the official JFK story–that a lone gunman killed President Kennedy out of “hatred for American society.” The CIA’s doubts only surfaced in the spring of 1975 when the official story was shredded by revelations about the agency’s pre-assassination knowledge of Oswald and plots to kill Castro.

The frame of the Politico story because it gives the CIA the benefit of the doubt on an issue where it has repeatedly lied and continues to stonewall in federal court. I sued the CIA for certain JFK files in 2003; fourteen years later, the case is still pending.

This is not to say Shenon and Sabato are CIA apologists. They are both deeply knowledgable about the JFK case, and I consider both of them friends. But I think their reading of the new files is too charitable to the CIA and too predictable in suggesting Castro might have been to blame.

They might have at least noted that the first “Castro Done It”conspiracy theory to reach public print 54 years ago, was paid for by a CIA undercover officer.

Lies of the Official Story

This much is certain: The Warren Commission relied on the CIA’s information in telling the American public about Oswald’s defection to the Soviet Union in October 1959, his return in June 1962, and his curious visit to Mexico City in October 1963.

As Shenon and Sabato note, perhaps too casually, senior CIA officials lied to the Warren Commission on each and everyone of these points. A dispassionate observer would say that the initial lies call in to question the sincerity of the later doubts.

In fact, Oswald had been monitored closely by the CIA’s Counterintelligence Staff from 1959 to 1963. CI chief James Angleton, personally controlled Oswald’s file for 48 months before JFK was killed. As of mid-November 1963, Angleton knew Oswald was in Texas, according to a declassified CIA record.

[I tell the story in my forthcoming Angleton biography, The Ghost: The Secret Life of CIA Spymaster James Jesus Angleton, available for pre-order now.]

Suffice it to say, the Politico headline is simplistic, if not misleading.

Richard Helms, CIA director

Richard Helms: The man who kept the JFK secrets

When the editors of Politico say “the CIA came to doubt” the official story by the mid-1970s, what they mean is the agency was forced to acknowledge that Angleton (and deputy director Richard Helms) had misrepresented what they knew about Oswald before JFK was killed.

If CIA officials doubted the official story of a lone gunman in the mid-1970s, it was because they realized the agency had some explaining to do. They knew that Oswald’s Cuban contacts had never been properly investigated. Two leaders of the CIA–Angleton and Helms–had personally prevented it.

What Politico Gets Right 

Shenon and Sabato get a couple things right in their article. The documents they call attention to are indeed the most significant new JFK assassination records to surface in the first batch of JFK records released online by the Nationals Archives on July 24.

The files, labeled “HELMS HEARING DUPLICATE,” were given to former CIA director Richard Helms in 1978. That’s when he imperious CIA man, once dubbed “the gentlemanly planner of assassinations,” was later summoned to testify secretly to Congress about his involvement in the CIA assassination plots against Castro and other foreign leaders.

Shenon and Sabato, note in passing that the documents came from Ray Rocca, identified as a “senior counterintelligence officer.” Rocca could be more accurately described as Angleton’s loyal deputy. The file was assembled by Rocca to assist in Helms’ defense.

What’s New?

The  new JFK files do not, in my view, support Shenon and Sabato’s recycled “Castro Done It” theory, which predictably points the figure of culpability at the Cuban government in Havana.

Rather these files, in their totality, tell a more disturbing story, which points to culpability in the U.S. government in Washington, and the CIA in Langley.

It is a story of obstruction of justice: how top CIA officials lied to the Warren Commission to prevent disclosure of the agency’s plots to kill Castro and to block investigation of Oswald’s role in two authorized CIA operations in the summer of 1963.

James Angleton was witting to all three.


Next: In 1964 CIA officials conspired to hide Castro assassination plots from the Warren Commission.

You can access the 157-page “HELMS HEARING DUPLICATE” file here, courtesy of




 The Ghost: The Secret Life of CIA Spymaster James Jesus Angleton.

The Ghost

James Angleton’s real life is the most intriguing, moving, and at time shocking spy story in American history. In The Ghost, Jefferson Morley has capture the man in all of his brilliant and sometimes delusional eccentricity.  A must read’ for anyone who wants to understand just how strange and secretive the CIA was at the height of the Cold War.

–David Ignatius, columnist for the Washington Post and author of The Director.

















  1. Steve Schwendeman says:

    Philip Shenon was also recently on NPR’s “Fresh Air”. He supports the “single bullet theory”. I was very surprised to see this considering the HSCA findings doubting the Warren Commission’s conclusion.

    Is this 2017 disinformation and could you please comment on what Shenon got wrong in the NPR article, which has been picked up by many other news outlets?

  2. david thurman says:

    Thanx 4 the heads up re: the 157 pg. “HELMS HEARING DUPLICATE.”; It’s at least a gold mine of little gems.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

In seeking to expand the range of informed debate about the events of 1963 and its aftermath, welcomes comments that are factual, engaging, and civil. more

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

male enhancement: make sexually penis sergury does ejaculation reduce testosterone what do penis pumps do penis enlarging pumps order viagra from canada produces testosterone do natural testosterone boosters work best supplements for ed what is a cockring androzene cost how to fix a hormonal imbalance sex drive wiki male to male sex how does a boner work it works product ingredients https quizlet what causes phimosis good smile company shop stretch u hidden penis surgery gmc health store near me mens for sex addyi walmart what does 69 mean sexually when to take viagra for best results sex normal how to make a fake dick silicone injected cock best male performance oysters testosterone how to gain girth size penis enlargening viagra type pills male enhancement tablets average penile girth

vape: smoke and vape shop vape bending good guy vapes what ecig flavors could be bad for you hexohm vape how to do vape tricks how to use a vape cartridge zmax ecig boomtown vapor im boycotting voopoo after the ridiculous bs on youtube primitive vapor smoking age in virginia nike football vapor cleats black beards bounty skittles vape juice canister close valve vaping mouth cancer what is the maximum puff feature on smok ecig gbox vape what is pg in vape juice vuse alto vape e cigarette unsafe vapes with big clouds e cigarette with coil smok species mod vaping how it works ultimate vape deals coupon weight gain switching to vaping imren 3200mah smokjoy ops 1 stick v8 baby kit nrg gt8 coils smok vape pen plus glass 3mg e liquid vapor lab louisville uwell caliburn contact disposable cbd vape

weight loss: bronkaid weight loss cinnamon honey tea for weight loss success weight loss weight loss calculator app anavar weight loss mint for weight loss weight loss clinic phentermine weight loss doctors tampa green smoothie weight loss plan how to take keto pills premarin and weight loss weight loss poster weight loss plant based diet paleo diet plan for weight loss indian lomaira weight loss does slimquick diet pills work invokana side effects weight loss saba ace weight loss pills weight loss diet for vegetarians weight loss clinic dallas paxil weight gain or loss ellie goulding weight loss icd9 weight loss pruvit weight loss reviews cheat day weight loss stomach brace weight loss avocado banana smoothie weight loss good diet pills to lose weight fast prescription diet pills list requirements for weight loss surgery new fda approved diet pills dr urshan weight loss cost dexedrine diet pills dr axe weight loss diet maxwell keto pills ally weight loss

exam: Welcome To Buy 9A0-090 Exam Collection Online Sale, Download Latest RDCR201 Exam Dumps With High Quality, Easily To Pass 642-067 Certification Braindumps With 100% Pass Rate, Most Reliable 640-861 Exam Vce Online Store, Most Hottest 350-018 Vce Files On Our Store, ITexam-Answers 642-372 Vce Dumps Will Be More Popular, Valid and updated HH0-260 Vce Software With New Discount, 100% Pass Guarantee HP0-D15 Exam Paper Pdf Is What You Need To Take, High Success Rate ACSO-NH-WK2-IJ-01 Real Exam Questions Is Your Best Choice, Certshared C4060-089J Test Questions And Answers Pdf , Exam-Labs 000-906 Study Guide Book Latest Version PDF&VCE, 100% Pass Rate A2160-669 Questions And Answers Pdf On Our Store, Most Hottest ZJN0-314 Study Material Is Your Best Choice, Buy Discount 070-663 Cert Exam Will Be More Popular, Exambible 70-431GB2312 Certification Answers Online Sale, 100% Pass MB7-225 Study Guide With Low Price, Welcome To Buy 070-162 Test Questions Will Be More Popular, Free C8010-241 Self Study On Store,

cbd oil: aceite de cbd what to use cbd oil for traveling with cbd oil internationally cbd oil definition cbd lemonade cbd studies charlottes web cbd for sale cbd cigarette nirvana cbd oil nih glioblastoma is cbd safe for elderly vaping for pain relief avid hemp cbd pharmacol biochem behav uws parramatta cbd cbd oil south korea sd cbd top cbd manufacturers hemp oil supplements fightback cbd anything and everything store superior cbd as well as cbd or thc for anxiety percocet que es football player cbd oil psychology research colorado peaks hemp weed background pictures straight hemp pheel goodz cbd oil weed in german will cbd oil kill worms cbd oil facts and myths gummy cbd oil tincture amount of cbd cbd w polsce legalne