Two different views of Antonio Veciana

After I published my review of Antonio Veciana’s book, Trained to Kill, for Newsweek, several people asked me about Dan Hardway’s review of the book AARC web site and W. Tracy Parnell’s blog, purporting to debunk Veciana’s story.

The former is an investigator’s take, the latter a prosecutor’s brief. Dan looks to get beyond Veciana’s self-presentation. Parnell seeks to impeach his credibility. Dan sees Veciana’s story as “modified limited hangout,” Parnell sees it as a fantasy.

Both are worth taking seriously.

Trained to KillHardway’s argument is reasonable–it might be true; Veciana may not have told us all he knows–but I’m not convinced that it definitely is true. Hardway’s intriguing theory requires more investigation.

Parnell’s argument is strained and self-righteous, complete with leading questions designed to deliver the reader into his conclusions. His theory requires no further investigation because he’s right, and if you disagree you’re a probably another pathetic “conspiracy theorist.”

In Parnell’s account Veciana is some guy who who made up a bunch of stories for no reason, one of which Gaeton Fonzi, allegedly a crazed conspiracy theorist, used to sell his own stupid conspiracy theory.

This cartoonish account is unfair to Fonzi who was a professional journalist and investigator, respected in his work, careful in his methods and open-minded in his thinking. Fonzi’s unlikely friendship with the young Bill O’Reilly attests to his generous personality. To caricature him as a “conspiracy theorist” doesn’t just ring false. It is false.

Parnell accuses me of a lack of critical thinking. But I think my review has a rather more rounded and detailed account of who Veciana was, something that Parnell, in his furious anti-conspiratorial preacher mode, never gets around to doing.

David Phillips

David A. Phillips

Who was Antonio Veciana, if he was not the man he says he was? Did he work for Che Guevara? (Yes.) Did he burn down the department story El Encanto? (He did.) Did he run Alpha 66? (Yes.) Was he identified as AMSHALE-1 in CIA files (Yes.) Did his cousin Guillermo Ruiz work for Cuban intelligence (Yes.) Was Veciana deeply involved in Cuban operations for more than a decade (Yes.) Who was his case officer, if it wasn’t David Phillip a.k.a “Maurice Bishop?”

Parnell has few answers for such questions because he’s actually not that interested in the history of the Cuban-American struggle for power. Like a lot of people, he’s more interested in conspiracy theories, than in facts.

For all his self-proclaimed expertise, Parnell’s knowledge base seems thin. What of Veciana’s account of how Alpha 66 was organized and run? What about Veciana’s divisive decision to bring leftist Eloy Gutierrez Menoyo into his movement? What about the testimony of CIA contract officer Ross Crozier who told Gaeton Fonzi (and then me) that Phillips did use the alias “Maurice Bishop?”

Such questions don’t delay Parnell from arriving at his anti-conspiratorial destination, . As a result, Parnell’s Veciana looks like more of a straw man, than a real man, which is why I found his arguments unconvincing.

Parnell is right about one thing. Wynne Johnson’s story is worthless as evidence.

 

 

 

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

In seeking to expand the range of informed debate about the events of 1963 and its aftermath, JFKFacts.org welcomes comments that are factual, engaging, and civil. more

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

exam: Prompt Updates 9A0-160 Preparation Materials Latest Version PDF&VCE, Certforall 9A0-055 Answers For All Candidates From All Over The World, Most Popular RCDD Study Guides Online Store, 100% Real A10 Vce Software Are The Best Materials, 100% Pass Rate 350-026 Exam Cram Is What You Need To Take, Prep4sure 200-120 Simulation Questions Will Be More Popular, 100% Pass Guarantee TE0-302 Guide With The Knowledge And Skills, Money Back Guarantee EE0-513 Preparation Materials Latest Version PDF&VCE, Discount EX0-104 Prep Guide Are The Best Materials, Prompt Updates HP2-061 Study Guides With Accurate Answers, Pass the HP2-N47 Prep Guide Online Sale, First-hand 000-M30 Vce With Low Price, Exam-Labs 000-917 Vce And Pdf For Sale, Find Best A2010-565 Test Questions Are Based On The Real Exam, 50% Discount M2050-653 Certification Exam For Sale, The Most Recommended LOT-836 Exam Vce Covers All Key Points, Sale Discount Apache-Hadoop-Developer Exam Questions And Answers Guaranteed Success, Latest 070-518-CSHARP Exam Materials Are The Best Materials, Topdump 070-453 Vce And Pdf With Low Price, High Success Rate 070-699 Practice Exam On Sale, 100% Pass CPCM Certification Material Is Your Best Choice, ITexam-Answers 050-864 Brain Dumps On Our Store, Buy 1Z1-552 Pdf With The Knowledge And Skills, Sale Latest 1Z0-061 Book Will Be More Popular, 100% Pass Guarantee PDDM New Questions Are The Best Materials, Reliable and Professional HP2-Z09 Exam Test For Each Candidate, Offer HP5-H01D Certificate 100% Pass With A High Score, Prompt Updates 250-504 Vce With Low Price, Certleader 156-915-70 Test Prep Is Updated Daily,

male enhancement: generic viagra in usa improve erection quality sildenafil 25mg how cock ring work viagra doesn t work best drug to have sex on how to use levitra dealing with ed viagra samples for sale erect circumcised penis penis enlargement remedy review corpus cavernosum function large erection contact number for spotify what is the average male pennis size penis thicken penis growing exercises to make your penis bigger teen dick size testosterone gel reviews increasing penis size naturally grow ur penis increase dick size naturally where can i buy generic viagra vigrx plus cvs how does viagra make you feel black male enhancement pill you make my dick hard tadalafil vs sildenafil ed cure exercise erectile dysfunction age 20 random penis super boner improving your sexlife vitamin d impotence really thick penis impotent meaning viagra cost with insurance caffeine and erections natural testosterone production customer service spotify at what age do you stop growing just big dicks pandora account sign in que es livido how much does rogaine cost nugenix for sale alpha prime elite amazon alpha titan testo side effects foods that make your penis bigger how to take testosterone booster yellow capsule pill extenze free 7 day trial average pen length what is the best penis pill erectile dysfunction implants the biggest pennis in d world biggest asian penis

cbd oil: cbd oil use the dab cbd clinic pro sport pain stick cbd kings cbd oil sleep aid pure cbd oil for pain samsung sd300 ny cbd hemp cbd business plan does cbd oil make you poop cbd and thc difference cbd pod creating better days cbd oil review property scientific definition best cbd brand reddit does cbd oil help with dementia green twist cbd best cbd cream with emu oil for pain hawaiian cbd tom hanks cbd oil what does cbd oil help with list remedy cannabis yoga pilates sydney cbd cbd for erectile dysfunction reddit melatonin and cbd together vital cbd best strain for neuropathy tram to melbourne zoo from cbd phoenix tears colorado dispensary kats cbd oil reviews how much definition how to smoke cbd crystals weed oil pills purity organic juice hemp oil sleep aid best cbd oil for diabetes type 1 positive side effects things to do while high componente en ingles sprouts cbd how many cbd receptors are in the human body can i use a crock pot to make cbd oil can cbd oil lower psa levels bluebird botanicals hemp cbd oil what strength cbd oil to use brightfield group cbd cbd oil in scappoose oregon cbd oil in marion il what cbd oil of bluebird botanicals cbd long island cbd oil in beaumont study marijuana 1000 mg cbd oil to treat cancer definition oil devine cbd oil can cbd oil show on a drug test washington post cbd oil cbd oil monroeville pa

vape: vfire vape vaping wicks purple vape tanks uwell watch vape vape shop hiring near me flying with vape juice rda vape coil is vaping illegal for minors wood grain box mod voopoo drag 2 images transoarent background white nike vapor cleats vapor barrier basements ecig fluid uwell valyrian leaking how many puffs are in a ecig nike vapor 3 wood for sale best diy vape juice e cigarette weed vaporizer which vape juice is thicker vapor pen cigarette best juice for vape tricks cool ecig mouth tips vape juice turns darker over time in tank nicotine vapes aspire e cigarette battery vertex vape pen instructions atomizer for e cigarette sales online rocket man vape juice e cigarette shop fuquay varina rafale uwell tank leak vaping history how to refill vape tank popular box mod smok repair 100 watt box mod vape twonk vape juice cheap rda for clouds vape pens how to use what does a dry hit taste like new vape juice cloud vape store mercual vapor iv update smok alien best starter vaporizer light up box mod smok vape pen plus user manual smok tfv4 tank glass vape vibe rebuilding uwell crown titanium coils smok fetch what coil is compatable with a uwell crown vape a tide pod dual coil tank u uwell where to buy vape pens voopoo tech china address uwell crown 2 ohms to high error voopoo vmate change ni vaporl reviews

weight loss: cbd oil weight loss water infusions for weight loss lemon water for weight loss katharine mcphee weight loss long term weight loss zac brown weight loss meal replacement weight loss how to take metformin for weight loss karl lagerfeld weight loss 120 mg cymbalta weight loss frozen meals for weight loss random weight loss nofap weight loss mexican weight loss pills weight loss diets that work weight loss shirt compression janelle brown weight loss 2017 low carb diet plan for weight loss cinnamon honey weight loss drink iu weight loss diet weight loss surgery nj robin egg diet pills roy nelson weight loss quick weight loss center kendall pcos weight loss plan zoloft weight loss calorie formula for weight loss tequila weight loss fennel for weight loss do nv diet pills work green tea for weight loss fast weight loss dinner recipes katie maloney weight loss andre leon talley weight loss diet weight loss pills detox liver for weight loss weight loss yoga for beginners at home weight loss amphetamine synedrex weight loss ab slim diet pills gabby weight loss precious weight loss columbus ga herbalife weight loss tea supplement to lose weight fast contour weight loss uams weight loss clinic weight loss pills green coffee rachael ray diet pills dr oz weight loss pills australia alli weight loss pills amazon phenterex diet pills reviews red capsule diet pills diet alli pills where can you buy weight loss pills adverse effects of diet pills the best weight loss supplements slim fit pills gluten free diet pills