Roger Stone’s valid JFK point: CIA is not complying with the law

Roger Stone

Roger Stone,

As President Trump’s April 26, 2018 deadline for release of the last of the government’s JFK files, Roger Stone, the sartorial dirty trickster of American politics, makes a legally valid point:

The CIA is not obeying the JFK Records Act.

Stone pointed out that the 1992 law which required the JFK documents be released also required the agency redacting records to justify their redactions in writing and that those explanations be published in the Federal Register.

Stone is political provocateur and performance artist with a penchant for misstatements of fact. Anything he says has to be handled with care. But in this case, he is correct.

Legal Requirement

Stone is referring to a specific passage in the JFK Records Act, Section 4 (g) (2) (B), which states

All postponed assassination records determined to require continued postponement shall require an unclassified written description of the reason for such continued postponement. Such description shall be provided to the Archivist and published in the Federal Register upon determination.

From the passage of the law in 1992 until 2017, the CIA and other agencies adhered to this passage, and did so scrupulously.

If the CIA released a JFK file to the National Archives with redactions, a coded comment in the margin gave an unclassified description of why information was withheld. Typical reasons were “national security,” “personal privacy” or “sources and methods.”

Here’s an example from the file of George Joannides, an undercover CIA officer who ran a secret program called AMSPELL that figured in the surveillance of Oswald in the summer of 1963.

Joannides redactions

(JFK redactions explained, according to law.)

A line of information has been blacked out and replaced with the words, “08-civil service grade.” That’s a coded reference to the fact that Joannides’ exact civil service grade was withheld on grounds of privacy.

The line below has been redacted and replaced with the number 23, a coded reference to withholding related to “sources and methods.”

In this document, the CIA adhered to the JFK Records Act; it explained what was withheld and why

Evidence of Non-Compliance

Now compare that with the recently released file of Birch D. O’Neal, the veteran counterintelligence officer who opened the CIA’s first file on Oswald in November 1959. The 224 pages of his file are rife with redactions, none of them explained.

Look at this 86-page file on “DRE/AMSPELL operations,” which were run by Joannides from August 1963 to May 1964. Sixty two pages of the file are withheld in full or in part. None of the redactions are explained as required by law.

Who’s to Blame?

Stone blames “the deep state” for this failure but President Trump is arguably responsible too. In his order of October 26, 2017, the president could have reminded the CIA and other government agencies of their legal obligation to explain any withholding decisions. He did not.

Perhaps the CIA will come into compliance by April 26. Perhaps not. It all depends on whether Trump is serious about enforcing the JFK Records Act, and so far the evidence is mixed.

The Mary Ferrell Foundation has pointed out the non-compliance of the CIA and other agencies in a letter to National Archivist David Ferriero. I will post the letter later today.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

In seeking to expand the range of informed debate about the events of 1963 and its aftermath, welcomes comments that are factual, engaging, and civil. more

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

exam: Best 642-444 Material Pdf Is The Best Material, Welcome To Buy 650-153 Study Material With High Quality, Easily To Pass HP0-Y41 Test Are The Best Materials, 100% Success Rate C4090-452 Test Are Based On The Real Exam, Ucertify 000-704 Certification Exam For Download, Provides Best C6030-041 Exam Dumps Pdf 100% Pass With A High Score, Buy Latest P2070-092 Certification Answers For Sale, Valid and updated IIA-CGAP Certification Braindumps For All Candidates From All Over The World, Best 070-541 Certification Dumps Is Your Best Choice, Free Download Real 1Z0-024 Test Questions And Answers Pdf With High Quality, Recenty Updated 1Z1-020 Certification Material With Low Price, Pass4sure ST0-91W Vce Files Is What You Need To Take, Passguide OG0-091 Sample Questions Online Store,

vape: cbd vape pen cartridge large vape juice x20 vape vape n juice rockford make own vape juice vape atomizer parts taylor gang vapor pen rba stand canister purge valve how to vape concentrates what does vape juice have in it diy vape juice no nicotine vaping lung illness symptoms t priv coils vaping hookah voopoo drag mini how to unlock nord by smok smoke rings tricks how to take apart smok stick v8 battery baton vape juice what is salt nic steampunk vape smok tfv4 mod smok vape osub smok marshal g320 kit vape pen hash oil cartridge

cbd oil: cbd 1000mg does cbd oil go rancid rainbow blossom cbd oil need information on full spectrum cbd distillate terpene cbd oil vape best wattage hemp oil cbd benefits doterra oil not cbd cbd oil medterra side effects from cbd lyft cbd vape liquid reviews relief definition in science cbd to lose weight cbd vs hemp oil for pain comes definition will cbd get me high marijuana cream for joint pain use is and are purchase cannabis oil for cancer does cbd oil help with eyesight most effective way to use cbd oil its dangerous to go alone take this heart purxpressions cbd oil cbd munchies what can cbd oil do to you kangaroo cbd reviews

weight loss: post weight loss surgery quick weight loss efa arginine weight loss prescription weight loss pills 2015 hctz weight loss true trim forskolin ballet beautiful weight loss results does acupuncture work for weight loss xanthohumol weight loss different types of weight loss surgery natural shakes for weight loss abby miller weight loss weight loss surgery diet plan quick weight loss women buy mzt diet pills free weight loss surgery japanese diet pills yellow forskolin for weight loss reviews burn x diet pills weight loss pills free trial boiled egg diet plan for weight loss approved fda diet pills pro forskolin christine carter weight loss keto max pills reviews the best prescription weight loss pills

male enhancement: non prescription ed pills stanozolol pill gainswave negative reviews magnum trt reviews penis enhance generic viagra teva penis pump ring the red pill for ed herbs for penis enlargement what does a percocet 30 look like best all natural testosterone booster small penis vs big penis natural foods to increase testosterone male sex enhancement pills ways to get hard sex and drive herbs that increase estrogen sex drives gay men penises reddit male enhancement nice looking dicks how to get rock hard instantly sex duration get a viagra perscription flibanserin cost does puberty hurt