The New York Times Evades Bob Dylan’s JFK Challenge

“Bob Dylan Has a Lot on His Mind,” the New York Times reported on June 12.  That’s for sure. In late March, as the COVID-19 pandemic shut down America, the 79 year old singer-songwriter released “Murder Most Foul,” an epic, 17-minute song-poem about the assassination of President John F. Kennedy.

Since “Who killed JFK?” is one of the central questions of American history, you might think that the Times interviewer, historian Douglas Brinkley would ask the Nobel laureate about how he came to compose his dark and brooding take on November 22, 1963. You might think Brinkley, a CNN commentator, would ask Dylan why he decided to release the song as the country and the world reeled from a plague.

You might think wrong.

Oswald dying
Lee Harvey Oswald denied killing JFK, saying he was “a patsy.” The next day he was killed in police custody.

Brinkley asked Dylan four questions about “Murder Most Foul,” none of which concerned Dylan’s thinking about how and why the liberal president was shot dead in broad daylight, and no one was ever brought to justice for the crime.

In “Murder Most Foul,” Dylan could not have been more explicit in his rejection of the dubious official story which holds Kennedy was killed by one man for no reason. Over a rippling guitar and piano accompaniment, Dylan growls out his biting dissent from the conventional wisdom about Dallas. 

The day they blew out the brains of the king
Thousands were watching; no one saw a thing
It happened so quickly, so quick, by surprise

Right there in front of everyone’s eyes
Greatest magic trick ever under the sun
Perfectly executed, skillfully done
Wolfman, oh wolfman, oh wolfman howl
Rub-a-dub-dub, it’s a murder most foul

In a telling display of the intellectual denial that usually dumbs down media discussion of JFK’s assassination, Brinkley did his best to evade the challenge of Dylan’s deeply political art. Brinkley (or perhaps his editors) did not care to mention the dread word of “conspiracy,” even though Dylan’s belief that JFK was killed by powerful enemies propels his stream of consciousness song from beginning to end.

Questions Dumb and Dumber

Dylan, well-versed in the case of the murdered president, makes his point obvious with cutting couplets. About the official story, he snarls I’m just a patsy/like Patsy Cline/Didn’t shoot nobody/from in front or behind.

Brinkley, adept at missing the point, asked “Was ‘Murder Most Foul’ written as a nostalgic eulogy for a long-lost time?”

That’s a weird description of an unsentimental song about the awful impact of a bloody deed. Dylan punted the question politely.

“To me it’s not nostalgic. I don’t think of ‘Murder Most Foul’ as a glorification of the past or some kind of send-off to a lost age. It speaks to me in the moment. It always did, especially when I was writing the lyrics out.”

“Somebody auctioned off a sheaf of unpublished transcripts in the 1990s that you wrote about J.F.K.’s murder,” Brinkey went on. “Were those prose notes for an essay or were you hoping to write a song like “Murder Most Foul” for a long time?”

“I’m not aware of ever wanting to write a song about J.F.K.” he replied, reminding his Brinkley that ‘Murder Most Foul’ is about a crime, not a politician. (Dylan added, “A lot of those auctioned-off documents have been forged. The forgeries are easy to spot because somebody always signs my name on the bottom.”)

Brinkley danced around the subject of JFK’s murder in favor of two themes, technology and hyper-industrialization, that appear exactly nowhere in Dylan’s song.

“There is a lot of apocalyptic sentiment in ‘Murder Most Foul,’ Brinkley said. “Are you worried that in 2020 we’re past the point of no return? That technology and hyper-industrialization are going to work against human life on Earth?

Dylan chided Brinkley for his solipsism.

“Sure, there’s a lot of reasons to be apprehensive about that,” he said, “There’s definitely a lot more anxiety and nervousness around now than there used to be. But that only applies to people of a certain age like me and you, Doug. We have a tendency to live in the past, but that’s only us. Youngsters don’t have that tendency. They have no past, so all they know is what they see and hear, and they’ll believe anything.”

A competent interviewer might have followed up by asking Dylan why he still cares about JFK’s death or what young people should believe about it. Instead, Brinkley closed by asking a question so lame as to be ludicrous

“Your mention of Don Henley and Glenn Frey on ‘Murder Most Foul’ came off as a bit of a surprise to me,” Brinkley said. “What Eagles songs do you enjoy the most?”

Huh? The greatest poet of his generation writes a complex saga about the most important assassination of the 20th century and releases it amid the biggest catastrophe of the 21st century–and this tenured historian inquires about the man’s taste in 1970’s soft rock. Now that is denial.

Never patient with clueless interviewers, Dylan replied facetiously.

“‘New Kid in Town,’ ‘Life in the Fast Lane,’ ‘Pretty Maids All in a Row.’ That could be one of the best songs ever,” he deadpanned. Brinkley probably thought he was serious.

When it comes to JFK”s assassination, Bob Dylan has a lot on his mind but the New York Times doesn’t dare talk about it.

Source: Bob Dylan Has a Lot on His Mind – The New York Times

10 comments

  1. Richard Turnbull says:

    All sound arguments and insights about our pathetic mass media, except for one aspect, Jeff: Dylan has extremely eclectic, open-minded tastes in music, as even a cursory review of his recordings make starkly clear, including songs that range from classic British ballads as collected by F.J. Child, through blues, gospel, country, Tin Pan Alley hits and more, so there’s no reason to vicariously reject the entire Eagles output as beneath Dylan’s standards. All kinds of bands and individual artists, all over the world, have written and performed some excellent music, even if it is true very few can be compared to Bob Dylan.
    Btw there is a link to this piece at kennedysandking.com, another site your readers will want to explore.

  2. Rick G. says:

    This comes as no surprise. The NYT ran point for the Warren Commission even before its findings and conclusions were made public in 1964. The Grey Lady has protected and perpetrated the LN fable for almost 57 years. In fact, since 11/22/63 they have been front and center in defense of the “official story” and have rarely if ever wavered in identifying Oswald as the lone assassin. They are not about to become honest about it now. People will demand to know why it took almost six decades.

  3. Patrick Hinton says:

    That’s outrageous! But at the same time not surprising. The major news media has been the leader in this great cover up of JFK’s murder. Douglas Brinkley is a coward! As is the New York Times, CNN and the like. There wasn’t one relevant question Brinkley brought forth as to why Dylan wrote this song and if he believes there was a plot to kill Jack Kennedy. Clearly his song demonstrates it was much more than Oswald. Today, to think Oswald really acted alone (if at all) is very comical, and naive, ignorant, childish, cowardice and fear driven. This was the most treasonous act in U.S. history. Thanks to: Angleton, Dulles, Hoover, Burkley, Clifton, Galloway, Stover, Paterni, Kellerman, LeMay, McHugh, Joannides, Phillips, Morales, Harvey…to name a few. People talk about social justice now and black lives matter, Trump or Biden. This is all a distraction and futile in the face of truth regarding the murder of JFK and overthrow of our government in 1963.

  4. Koga says:

    This program is on Japanese TV. Oswald used to live in Japan and new information has been uncovered.
    Oswald and JFK UNSOLVED CASES Part 2: The Chessmaster – NHK WORLD PRIME | NHK WORLD-JAPAN On Demand
    https://www3.nhk.or.jp/nhkworld/en/ondemand/video/3016075/

  5. robert e williamson jr says:

    I guess maybe Mr. Brinkley’s performance in this interview might be adversely affected by the current wave of “fear and loathing” (per HST) that has cast a pall on the country.

    Maybe his “survival instinct” dampened his efforts during what should have been a fascinating interview.

    Thanks Jeff

  6. […] Is this murder most foul simply an odd coincidence?   The Bob Dylan mural at Hennepin and 5th in Minneapolis is not near any area of disturbance… Wherever he is, he is not here… Until today…June 12, 2020… https://www.nytimes.com/2020/06/12/arts/music/bob-dylan-rough-and-rowdy-ways.html when he said this one day after the murder of George Floyd… “It sickened me no end to see George tortured to death like that,” he said. “It was beyond ugly. Let’s hope that justice comes swift for the Floyd family and for the nation.” Impressive, Mr. Dylan.  The world listens to you… But apparently not the New York Times, who failed to ask Dylan a single question about how he became so passionate about the JFK assassination and why he is sure it was a conspiracy, and not the work of one man acting alone.  In fact, the Ongoing Coverup of the JFK assassination tends to do this at the level of the press.  They troll conspiracy but then end up with “that silly little Communist did it,” which is, of course, a redux of the failed Warren Commission Report.  Dylan has challenged this, and it is to his credit. My colleague Jefferson Morley has written an insightful essay on the questions the NYT failed to ask Dylan: https://jfkfacts.org/in-a-laughable-interview-the-new-york-times-evades-bob-dylans-jfk-challenge/ […]

  7. Mark Szczygiel says:

    Thank you! I wasn’t aware of this interview. It’s so maddening that so called experts get to sanitize our history.

  8. Martin Meenagh says:

    One gets tenure in America by neither asking troubling questions nor having troubling thoughts. I agree with everything in your article except your characterisation of Kennedy’s death as ‘the most important assassination of the twentieth century.’ Surely that dubious honour goes to the events in Sarajevo in June 1914? Dallas was a close second though, and I would suggest as you probably would that most of the things which have poisoned America over the past half century or so can be traced back to there.

  9. Dennis Jones says:

    There were two gunman on 11/22/63. End of story. But guess what? After 57 years, the truth is still well hidden. But truth is a rare thing. Especially now days.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

In seeking to expand the range of informed debate about the events of 1963 and its aftermath, JFKFacts.org welcomes comments that are factual, engaging, and civil. more

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.