Why did the CIA’s Angleton want to cut off questions about Oswald?

In response to my recent post on a declassified April 1972 CIA memo ordering that “no defector or source” be asked about Lee Harvey Oswald, a faithful reader asks:

Where is April 1972 in the Nosenko chronology? Was there a time at which saner CIA people simply told Angleton to back off from his Nosenko-KGB theories?

The answer is that Angleton was motivated both by his interest in Nosenko and his desire to block CIA people from questioning the dubious official story of Oswald as a lone assassin about whom the agency knew little.

In fact, as Angleton knew better than anyone, the CIA had monitored Oswald’s movements, politics, personal life, and foreign contacts for four years before JFK was killed.

The other relevant question is, “Where is April 1972 in the Oswald chronology?”

I provide a more detailed answer in my forthcoming book The Ghost: The Secret Life of The GhostCIA Spymaster James Jesus Angleton, but I will summarize the complex story here.

State of the Nosenko Case in 1972

The case Yuri Nosenko had been resolved to the satisfaction of the CIA leadership by the spring of 1972.

To recap one of the most famous spy vs. spy episodes of the Cold War, Nosenko was KBG officer who defected to the United States in January 1964 with the promise of a $50,000 payment and an annual salary of $25,00 for an indefinite period.

Nosenko said, among other things, that he had seen the KGB’s file on Oswald and that it contained nothing incriminating about the Soviet intelligence agency.

Angleton and other counterintelligence officers didn’t believe Nosenko’s story and persuaded Helms to renege on the agreement. Nosenko was detained, without judicial authorization, at a secret CIA facility in Clinton, Maryland and later at the CIA’s Camp Peary in Virginia, (what would now be called “black sites.”)

Nosenko was not tortured but he did endure solitary confinement and hostile interrogation for four years. Angleton believed that Nosenko was a false defector and he set out, in the words of Soviet Bloc division chief David Murphy to “break” him.

The new JFK releases contain extensive documentation of the Nosenko affair, including tape recordings and interrogation reports, which will shed new light on this murky affair.

Suffice it say,  Nosenko never confessed. A group of CIA officers who believed Nosenko was bona fide defector pressed to have Nosenko removed from Angleton’s control. These officers included George Kisevalter, the agency’s top Russian speaking agent handler, and Len McCoy, an officer in the Soviet Bloc division.

Yuri Nosenko, KGB

Yuri Nosenko, controversial KGB defector

A fierce bureaucratic struggle ensued which “nearly wrecked” the CIA’s Soviet operations. The struggle was finally resolved by deputy director Rufus Taylor in October 1968, who ruled against Angleton and his allies. Nosenko was released in early 1969 and resettled, at CIA expense, first in the Washington DC metropolitan area and then in North Carolina.

Angleton and his acolytes continued to believe that Nosenko was a false defector and continued to search for evidence to confirm this theory. Around this time, Richard Helms, a close friend of Angleton, asked CIA officer John Hart to review the case. Hart concluded that Nosenko was a bona fide defector. He wrote up his findings in a classified report called “The Monster Plot,” and in a open source book, The CIA’s Russians, which contains a lucid account of the whole affair.

So, to answer the reader’s question, the Nosenko case was effectively closed by April 1972 By that time, Angleton’s reputation as a paranoid conspiracy theorist was growing within the Agency.

So the readers’ question is worth asking: were saner CIA types simply seeking to get Angleton to back off?

The answer is no. A close reading of the April 1972 memo shows that it did not come from Nosenko believers (like Kisevalter, McCoy and Hart) who wanted to shut down Angleton’s inquiry.

To the contrary, the memo was sent by an Angleton loyalist, his longtime deputy Ray Rocca, identified in the memo as DC/CI (deputy chief, Counterintelligence). Angleton, through Rocca, had arranged for the prior approval of Dick Helms, who was a Nosenko skeptic himself. Rocca did not issue any orders that were not approved by his boss.

The order was not directed at Angleton, but at the SB/CI, the counterintelligence office of the Soviet Bloc division. The order asserted that the Counterintelligence Staff, not the Soviet Bloc division, would handle Oswald-related questions.

In other words, the April 1972 memo was not designed to shut down Angleton’s mole hunt. It was an expression of Angleton’s desire to continue the mole hunt that had largely been shut down.

But the memo, I believe,  was was also motivated by a desire to control unwanted questions about Oswald, who had denied he shot JFK before being killed in police custody.

State of the Oswald Case in 1972

Oswald in Custody

Oswald: “I’m a patsy”

Why do I say this?

First, because Angleton had long monitored skeptics of the official story that Oswald acted alone.

In 1968, he set up the so-called Garrison Group within the Counterintelligence Staff to spy on New Orleans prosecutor Jim Garrison who tried to make a conspiracy case against businessman Clay Shaw, who had served as a “highly paid CIA contract source” in the 1950s, according to a CIA historian.

When Garrison set up a national committee to reopen the JFK investigation in 1969, Angleton asked the FBI for more information on the group’s members. When Warren Commission critics held a conference in 1973, Angleton sent a colleague to spy on the proceedings.

In short, Angleton kept tabs on people who doubted Oswald’s sole guilt.

More importantly, the April 1972 memo was not the first time Angleton sought to shut down questions about Oswald inside the CIA. It was the third instance, and the other two had nothing to do with Nosenko.

The first time is documented in Phil Shenon’s book, A Cruel and Shocking Act.

In September 1969, Angleton received a detailed report from the State Department, written by Charles Thomas, an earnest Foreign Service Officer stationed in Mexico in the 1960s, who had investigated Oswald’s visit to Mexico in September 1963.

Thomas had spoken with several Mexicans who recalled meeting Oswald. He collected credible evidence that Oswald had some kind of relationship with Silvia Duran, an employee of the Cuban Consulate in Mexico City, who was known to the CIA for her good looks and communist sympathies. Thomas’s evidence was sufficient to convince Mexico City station chief Win Scott that Oswald had a sexual relationship with Duran. 

Thomas felt obliged to report what he knew to Washington, assuming the FBI or the CIA, would want to know more about Oswald’s Cuban contacts. The FBI wasn’t interested. So State Department referred Thomas’ reporting to Angleton.

No one outside the CIA knew it at the time, but Angleton had known all about Oswald’s visit to Mexico City six weeks before JFK was killed. His staff had prepared two cables about it that were sent to various Washington agencies and to Win Scott.  The existence of these cables was not known in 1969.Our Man in Mexico

Angleton also knew that all personnel at the Cuban Consulate where Duran worked were presumed to work for Cuban intelligence. Yet. Angleton wasn’t interested in Thomas’s information. He replied to the State Department with a note stating he saw “no need for further action.”

The second time Angleton suppressed Oswald information around this time is documented in my book, Our Man in Mexico.

It happened in April 1971. When Mexico City station chief Win Scott suddenly died, Angleton went to Mexico City and seized Scott’s unpublished memoir. In the memoir, Scott flatly–and accurately–disputed a key finding of the Warren Commission.

The commission’s final report stated (on p. 777) that the CIA had not learned of Oswald’s visit to the Cuban Consulate until after the assassination of JFK. That was a lie and Scott knew that it was a lie. His photo and audio surveillance operations reported on all visitors to the Consulate  No American came and went the doors of the Consulate without Scott being informed within 24 hours. Oswald’s visit to the Consulate on September 27, 1963 were no exception.

Angleton seized Scott’s manuscript and shared it with no one.

So, a year later, in April 1972, when Angleton learned that the Soviet Bloc division asked Soviet defector, Oleg Layalin about Oswald, the counterintelligence chief had two good reasons to seek cut off questions. He wanted to pursue the mole hunt and he wanted to cut off unwanted inquiries into Oswald’s past.

**************

PRE-ORDER NOW

The Ghost: The Secret Life of CIA Spymaster James Jesus Angleton.

The Ghost by Jefferson Morley

The Ghost is the compulsively readable, often bizarre true-life story of American spymaster James Jesus Angleton – the CIA’s poetry-loving, orchid-gardening mole-hunter for almost 20 years. Capturing the extent of Angleton’s eccentricity, duplicity and alcohol-fueled paranoia would have challenged the writing skills of a Le Carre or Ludlum, and Jefferson Morley has done it with flair. This important book depicts the trail of wreckage left behind by Angleton in a CIA career that involved him in virtually every major spy-versus-spy drama of the Cold War and drew him deeply into the mysteries of the Kennedy assassination and the murder of one of JFK’s mistresses.”
—Philip Shenon, author of A Cruel and Shocking Act

 

Click here to pre-order: The Ghost: The Secret Life of CIA Spymaster James Jesus Angleton.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

2 comments

  1. Thomas says:

    Are you aware that John Newman, summarizing and explaining what Tennent H. Bagley wrote, recently convinced Peter Dale Scott that Nosenko was a false defector?

  2. Thomas says:

    PS His name was Oleg Lyalin, not Oleg Layalin.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

In seeking to expand the range of informed debate about the events of 1963 and its aftermath, JFKFacts.org welcomes comments that are factual, engaging, and civil. more

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

weight loss: before and after weight loss tumblr tx weight loss center austin homemade body wraps for weight loss sara ali khan weight loss nexplanon removal weight loss waist weight loss best protein drink for weight loss contrave diet pills gabourey weight loss keisha renee weight loss mama june 2016 weight loss dulcolax for weight loss no carb diet plan for weight loss weight loss plateau solutions low carb vegetable soup weight loss clen diet pills peloton for weight loss stair climber weight loss gym workouts weight loss 3 days it diet pills chelsea houska weight loss diet jorie weight loss oak brook synedrex weight loss weight loss fort myers weight loss home made drinks zija diet pills slim extreme weight loss pills pills to help lose weight quickly weight loss pills with orlistat al gore weight loss tapeworm diet pills for sale weight loss through hypnosis diet pills that get you high my custom weight loss cost where can i buy lipro diet pills gastric ballooning weight loss safe diet pills for belly fat diet for weight loss best diet pills free trial metabo speed diet pills malaysia diet pills new diet pills 2015 quick weight loss yoga weight loss ab workout diet plan for quick weight loss in urdu cake boss weight loss quick vegan weight loss plans kirstie alley weight loss matt damon weight loss diet kelly clarkson 2013 weight loss garlic diet weight loss extreme weight loss full episodes hclf vegan diet weight loss weight loss pills obesity nutriverse keto pills reviews sauerkraut and weight loss

male enhancement: viagra timing herbal erection pill how to buy pills online testogen where to buy blood flow enhancers ed vacuum pumps reviews what does a penis pump do foods to improve testosterone large head penis sexual performance enhancers different size penis clomid dosage for male how to get your penius bigger sexual stamina products synthetic penis isosorbide drug class what is the best testosterone grockme pills rock hard supplement cocaine and viagra price of viagra do sperm volume pills work images of erect penis erect on demand reviews blood penis best looking penises organic erectile dysfunction traction method penile extender getting soft during sex ed pills for sale romans promo code how to get hard boners dollar beard club growth oil review supplement for sex drive man with smallest penis blue pain pill essential oils for sexual arousal blue pill with r on it list of sexual disorders how to give yourself an erection test boost and nitric oxide better than vigrx plus verutum rx big pennies in the world brain stimulating pills lil float erectile dysfunction mv7 pills exercise for sex stamina bigger harder penis nugenix reviews from customers male enhancement creams and oils uncircumsised penis photos pinas enlargement penuma implant male enhancement water pump ageless male ingredients

exam: The Best 9A0-099 Practice Online Store, Sale Latest 642-061 Vce And Pdf Covers All Key Points, First-hand BI0-132 Practice Exam Pdf With Low Price, Pass4sure ACSO-IPG-PROD-12-01 Test Answers Is The Best Material, Recenty Updated 000-713 Exam Guide Pdf Is Updated Daily, Free Download Real 000-714 Exam Test Questions Will Be More Popular, New Release 000-M26 Ebook Pdf Sale, Exambible C4040-120 Ebook On Our Store, High Pass Rate C2090-612 Exam Sample Questions 100% Pass With A High Score, Provides Best HP2-N31 Exam Test Online Shop, Certleader 000-564 Labs With Low Price, First-hand A2010-578 Certification Material Are The Best Materials, Latest Upload C2010-658 Prep Guide On Our Store, Ucertify LOT-987 Sample Questions , Discount 000-N37 Dump Test Is Your Best Choice, Valid and updated JN0-102 Vce Download With Accurate Answers, Provides Best 070-463 Exam Collection For All Candidates From All Over The World, Helpful 070-089 Certification Guaranteed Success, High Pass Rate 070-652 Answers Sale, Buy 920-442 Test Questions And Answers Pdf Latest Version PDF&VCE, Buy Discount OMG-OCEB-B200 Cert Guide Are The Best Materials, Exam-Labs 1Z0-860 Test Questions On Our Store, Certshared 050-V71X-CSESECURID Vce Download Online Sale, Up To Date HP3-R95 Preparation Materials Online, To Pass Your Exam SD0-101 Braindump , Buy 251-311 Vce Dumps For All Candidates From All Over The World, Examcollection ST0-250 Certification With The Knowledge And Skills, Exampassok 9L0-066 Exam Paper Pdf Online Shop,

vape: uwell nunchaku uwell checkmate best vape pen for cartridges e cigarette no smoking policy vape pen for cbd original voopoo alternate vape how to get uwell crown tank apart stuck vape caviar coupons sense sidekik washington vape co small e cig mods myvaporstore discount code hiw much is a lotus ecig battery vapor wave art vape shopes how to clean ecig ego vape starter kit how long should i let vape juice steep vapor 55 e cigarette liquid using a e cigarette in the plane bathroom e swisher e cigarette e cigarette des moines ia e cigarette shopping la vape shop e cigarette with sales numbers top vapor v8 baby t8 coils thin vape juice best device for nic salts best sites for vape juice box mod vape parts ecigarette canada vape pen pieces voopoo vape too change to hard hit easy vape mods vape juice depot coupon salt nicotine vs freebase nicotine vaping paraphernalia used vape gear for sale nunchaku uwell 80 watt atomizer subox nano starter kit smok t priv reviews suno refund card next big thing vape juice best e liquid 2019 man from nantucket vape juice tugboat box mod white kief in vape juice boosted box mod rebirth rda uwell crown 2 taste whiskey flavored vape juice voopoo drag how to remove uwell best tank

cbd oil: can doctors prescribe cbd oil cbd and restless leg cbd shots cbd drops for anxiety how to use a cbd vape pen cbd tank buy cbd oil for anxiety buy cannabidiol smokable cbd flower hemp oil vs cbd oil healing labs cbd oil cbd legal in oklahoma cbd clinic level 5 side effects cbd oil and skin cbd logo ideas hemp derived cbd products does cbd oil show up on blood work who sells cbd oil near me cbd for acne scars green roads cbd pain cream reviews social cbd drops should i also use the sticks in pot when i make cbd oil cannabis for nerve pain wellspring cbd review instagram customer service number cbd oil natural partners where to buy oil diabetes 101 top hookah flavours montana hemp thc causing seizures pen def what is the definition of more does all things groovy in chattanooga tn sell cbd oil huntingtons disease where to buy cbd oil in colorado you like my product how long before cbd oil is out of your system bp pens when is the best time to take cbd oil how do you know if mayo is bad kannaway cbd oils snowwolf mfeng how much should cbd oil cost cannabis oil images cbd bank dubai yoder cbd oil cbd oil and seroquel provida cbd oil reviews cbd oil hot flashes cbd oil cdl license co2 cbd extraction machine what is the recommended mg for cbd oil to vape dosing of cbd is cbd oil available in united states high dose cbd gummies