The whole Bay of Pigs thing

In face of a persistent legal challenge from the National Security Archive, the CIA continues to resist releasing an internal history of the failed invasion at the Bay of Pigs more than a half century ago. The struggle for Volume 5, as the history is known, is an epic legal contest

Why the secrecy about something that happened so long ago?

That question was the subject of a recent historian’s roundtable: National Security Archive v. Central Intelligence Agency.

Kenneth McDonald, one of the historians who participated, has actually read the forbidden document. He said the research in Volume 5 is “impressive.”

” I nevertheless found that the work had serious deficiencies as a historical study,” McDonald went on. “I was especially troubled by three particular weaknesses. First, the work was an apologia, an uncritical defense of the officers and operatives most closely involved with the operation. Second, without adequate argument or evidence it put responsibility for the operation’s failure on officers elsewhere in CIA and on US government officials up to the highest levels. Third, the work’s polemical response to earlier critics of the operation (especially those within the CIA) strongly suggested that [author Jack] Pfeiffer undertook his history principally as a rebuttal to such earlier critiques as the June 1961 findings of General Maxwell Taylor’s presidential commission and the October 1961 report of CIA Inspector General Lyman Kirkpatrick, both of which assessed the operation’s many faults in planning and execution.”

The CIA is keeping secret its harsh internal reaction to JFK’s handling of the Bay of Pigs.

9 comments

  1. Bill Banks says:

    Last volume just released. “Quicky version” is to read the intro and the last paragraph on page 159. I believe the technical term is FUBAR–and that applies to the executive branch as well. Could this be an explanation for Bobby’s subsequent amateur–anybody could do better than this–hour approach to Cuban matters?

    http://nsarchive.gwu.edu/NSAEBB/NSAEBB564-CIA-Releases-Controversial-Bay-of-Pigs-History/C01254908.pdf

  2. gerry campeau says:

    “Jeff, could you possibly expound on “The struggle for Volume 5″ ?
    I’ve read some on the BOP but appreciate info I’ve not seen yet as it’s a relevant subject.”
    Jeff as this is related too my ? to you on Doc Richardson, Its disapointing that you do not respond to our ?

  3. Ronnie Wayne says:

    Jeff, could you possibly expound on “The struggle for Volume 5” ?
    I’ve read some on the BOP but appreciate info I’ve not seen yet as it’s a relevant subject.

  4. Jay sutherland says:

    I doubt that it is anymore complicated than a few simple facts. There was no real intelligence showing a popular uprising against Castro once invasion began. There WAS an asumption that when the operation beagn to collapse like a house of cards that JFK would cave and involve US military. He correctly said no and the incompetent CIA was left with egg on their face. The same CIA that would later arm and assist Osama Bin Laden.

    • Bill Clarke says:

      Jay Sutherland August 16, 2014 at 9:23 pm

      Many people blame the lack of air support for the failure of the operation (it wasn’t) but the only way the operation could have been successful, if at all, was for the Cuban population to rise up against Castro. As you point out, there was no reason for us to think that this would happen. In fact Castro was still popular at the time.

      But one must remember that the CIA was following the presidents order for the BOP and the Afghanistan operations. They didn’t simply strike out on their own to do these operations.

      • Larry Hancock says:

        Actually the final CIA operation was not even close to that which Eisenhower had authorized – which was an infiltration effort to energize the on island insurgency. Its totally unclear that JFK was made aware how much the operation had changed; there was no discussion with Eisenhower. As Bill says, the CIA was not striking out on its own but in those early days they were given far more operational autonomy and they were “trusted”. The failure at the Bay of Pigs pretty well eroded that level of trust. However even as late as the CIA efforts against the Soviets in Afghanistan, the field was not reporting all its activities to CIA headquarters – thinks like supplying advanced sniper rifles and materials/training on IED’s.

  5. Larry Hancock says:

    McDonald’s observations have been made by others who read the last section as well. One obvious reason to keep it secret is that it so clearly shows that the Agency was not willing to take the responsibility for its own internal failures and that in essentially dismissing its own investigation, once again proved untrustworthy in regard to admitting and correcting its own management and security mistakes.

    Withholding such information is basic career and agency image CYA, but the CIA is certainly not the only agency which does it. The State Department has released, pulled back and still withholds a number of documents on Africa which appear to reflect poorly on Mr. Kissinger. Of course the ones we can see are pretty bad in and of themselves.

  6. Lawrence Schnapf says:

    I believe the Bay of Pigs is at the heart of the JFK assassination and also played a big role in the Watergate coverup.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

In seeking to expand the range of informed debate about the events of 1963 and its aftermath, JFKFacts.org welcomes comments that are factual, engaging, and civil. more

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

vape: vape for thc oil e cigarette buy india squawk box vape voopoo find s trio kawaii vape pen x4 coils best vape battery mod smok stick v8 baby starter kit how does water enter the atmosphere turtle blood vape juice houiser ecig vape coil building tools reliable e cigarette store online forum smok m80 pro v8 baby stick nearest vapor shop vape tops vape juice without pg is nicotine salt bad for you vape clearomizers vapetasia royalty 2 review e cig tank voopoo vape pod cloud evo vape voopoo mojo size nicotine poisoning e cig

exam: Pass the 156-110 Labs For Download, Ucertify 200-001 Vce Files 100% Pass With A High Score, Provide New 640-461 Exam Topics UP To 50% Off, Valid and updated ACSO-NH-WK1-IJ-01 Labs Online, Reliable and Professional C2180-318 Actual Exam For Sale, Sale Latest 000-M68 Practice Questions With New Discount, To Pass Your Exam 000-669 Testing Online, Examcollection 00M-620 Dump Test Is Your Best Choice, Prompt Updates BH0-010 Book Pdf Is What You Need To Take, Most Hottest MB5-645 Exam Dumps Pdf With 100% Pass Rate, 100% Pass 1Z1-599 Certification Answers Is The Best Material, 50% OFF SZ0-260 Answers Is The Best Material, Latest Release 310-053 Actual Questions With High Quality,

cbd oil: bhang cbd spray current naturals cbd oil vs pure kind botanicals cbd oil ritual cbd cbd oil methylation sydney cbd map cbd for gout dosage of cbd for anxiety 25 best cbd oils cbd oil vape kit zilis ultra cell topical johannesburg cbd cbd oil for neuropathy in the feet hempworx cbd bath bombs cbd gummies by live green hemp cbd oil hidradenitis suppurativa can you get addicted to cbd oil cbd home does cbd need to be decarboxylated definition therapy cbd oil quotes colorado cyclist coupon code coconut oil depression mayo clinic heart diet before surgery tainted translate susans cbd oil cbd file

male enhancement: building sexual stamina how to get a hardon fast healthy sexual relationship red monkey pills new ed meds viagra like foods measure dick over counter viagra how to make your cock big what fors average size pennis 17 year old penis head enlargement cant get hard enough zyrexin ultra quizlet list 16 contact number for spotify legit rom sites andro400 cost pimples on penile shaft does smoking cause impotence power donut hair how to close spotify account volume sperm pills rubbing penises best male enhancement for girth std tests walmart

weight loss: adrienne bailon weight loss diet pill live in weight loss camps for adults good weight loss calcium d glucarate weight loss carson daly weight loss best salads for weight loss weight loss women over 50 does buspar cause weight loss exercise diet pills best weight loss exercise programs as seen on tv weight loss pills elliptical vs running for weight loss weight loss quotes funny casein protein before bed weight loss ideal weight loss clinic will medicaid pay for weight loss pills prescription diet pills that work 2017 alli diet pills coupon best and safest diet pills for women long term prescription diet pills 3 day dry fast weight loss orihiro night diet pills review best weight loss app for apple watch are keto pills a fad diet healthy weight loss supplements