The fading taboo against Warren Commission critics

“When it comes to the assassination of President John F. Kennedy, the list of important, seemingly credible public figures who count themselves as conspiracy theorists is long and impressive,” Phil Shenon writes in today’s Washington Post

And now a former Warren Commission investigator has come out to say he no longer believes in the Commission’s finding. Charles Shaffer, former prosecutor who served Robert Kennedy’s representative to the Warren Commission, is a “Mafia done it” man.

Shaffer’s opinion isn’t particularly well-informed, but it is important. Shenon’s story matters more as a sign that the taboo against saying JFK was killed by his political enemies is fading, even in the upper ranks of the Justice Department, even in the newsroom of the Washington Post. 

Shaffer bases his opinion on the statements of Mafia attorney Frank Ragano who says that crime boss Santos Trafficante boasted of killing Kennedy. The problem is that Ragano’s statements cannot be corroborated.

A faithful reader calls attention to Anthony Summers’ judicious treatment of the matter in his excellent book, Not in Your Lifetime.

“While some have expressed belief in Ragano’s account, this author finds the Trafficante ‘confession’ story dubious. The author looked into whether Trafficante was where Ragano said he was on the day Ragano said he met with him, and decided it was unlikely, if not impossible. Exposing Ragano as a liar, however, would not dispose of the ‘Mob dunnit’ theory — nor of the notion that Trafficante and Marcello played some part in Kennedy’s murder. For more detail on the author’s probe of the Ragano story, see “Ghosts of November,” Vanity Fair, December 1994.”

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

16 comments

  1. Dan says:

    The Shenon piece makes mention that the CIA did not inform the Warren Commission of CIA/Mafia plots to assassinate Castro. In fact, Allen Dulles knew of these plots and did not inform his fellow commissioners. Shenon cites the CIA/Mafia plots as possible motive for retaliation by Castro. However they are important for another reason as well- the CIA/Mafia plots were part of the CIA Executive Action program that trained riflemen to assassinate by sniper fire, using both CIA and Mafia personnel. The CIA/Mafia plots should have been a focus for investigation to determine if they were connected to the events in Dallas.

  2. BradR says:

    The fact that a Warren investigator believes that there may be a Mafia connection is more important than blowing off why he believes it.
    I doubt that Shaffer or anybody else on the Commision knew about Oswald’s uncle being part of the Marcello organization or how influential he was with Oswald.
    I believe that the Mafia ties were coming out when Garrison launched his witch hunt that involved everybody but the Mob. How convenient for the gentleman described by Garrison as only a N.O. businessman. That comedy set back conspiracy investigations for years, until Garrison apologists like Stone and DiEugenio completely dismissed the Oswald and Ruby documented connections to the Mob and endorsed Garrison’s transparent attempt to divert attention away from Marcello, Hoffa, Trafficante and the rest.
    I believe that this was put out by John Davis in the early 90s with a bunch of other investigators, since overshadowed by the more sensationalist theories.

    • anonymous says:

      ” Garrison launched his witch hunt that involved everybody but the Mob”

      Didn’t Garrison’s witch hunt involve the CIA? The District Attorney of New Orleans, believed the assassination had been the work of CIA.

      Everybody but the Mob? Wasn’t it the Warren Commissions mr. Hoover of the FBI that denied the very existence of the mob?

    • Alex S says:

      Let’s be serious… Ruby was dripping with mob ties, but trying to make Dutz Murret the key to a plot linking Oswald to Marcello has always been the weakest point of any mob-did-it theory.

      Garrison case aside, there is nothing “sensationalist” about positing Oswald ties to the intelligence community and right-wing political operatives. Even if he was unwitting of the milieu in which he moved, it was a milieu defined by CIA/military intel ties, NOT racketeering.

  3. Neil says:

    I’m happy to see the Washington Post once again take the lead on publishing articles written by Warren Commission critics but that was a poorly written article. It seems to imply that the only “respectable” Conspiracy Theorists are government insiders. Worse, he wastes space talking about a Warren Commission staffer who believes Frank Ragano.

  4. Frank says:

    From the article:

    “Warren bears much of the responsibility for his commission’s failures. Years later, he would admit that, in his own mind, he ruled out a conspiracy within days of the president’s murder. As a result, he frequently blocked staff lawyers from pursuing lines of investigation that might have pointed to co-conspirators.”

    Ah, the sweet sound of truth. More to come I’m sure.

    • Photon says:

      If you read the article his ” long and impressive list” isn’t long at all-and the principal figure Shaffer still believes Oswald was the lone gunman.
      After 50 years not a shred of physical evidence linking Oswald to the Mafia, CIA, Cubans (pro and anti-Castro) or frankly anybody.
      If Oswald didn’t pull the trigger, who did?

      • Frank says:

        “If Oswald didn’t pull the trigger, who did?”

        Firstly why assume he didn’t? That and other conspirators are not mutually exclusive. This was probably a diversionary remark by you to derail the thread. Why devolve into useless assumptions specific to that point within this broader context of a botched job by the Warren Commission? The point isn’t were the conclusions correct, the point is they can’t be valid given an admittedly (by Earl Warren no less!) stunted and incomplete investigation. That is why the report was never accepted. It reeked of its own incompleteness.

        Secondly, if Warren had not “frequently blocked staff lawyers from pursuing lines of investigation that might have pointed to co-conspirators”, then we would know much, much more than we know today. Bad job, WC. Waste of taxes.

        Lastly, that single acknowledgement by Warren alone is enough to fully justify the immediate declassification and release of the many documents still being withheld to this very day. Don’t you agree? Certainly you should, but we all know you won’t.

        Meanwhile, we all watch and wait.

      • Arnaldo M Fernandez says:

        Your argument is the classical Only Game in Town fallacy. The key is not who did it, but rather that Oswald couldn´t do it. See:
        http://www.ctka.net/2014/The%20evidence%20is%20the%20conspiracy.html

      • Photon, I presume you mean “pull the trigger” that was the fatal shot? The only reason people claim it was Oswald is that that’s what John Edgar Hoover wanted people to believe. Doesn’t mean he was the one. He certainly didn’t fire the fatal shot…it was too difficult an angle from the TSBD.

  5. Allen Lowe says:

    the mob thing makes no sense; you have to look at the question of motivation on the part of investigators – a Mafia conspiracy would have been troublesome but not threatening to the stability of the government. So one can assume that, if it were likeley, police and WC investigators would have gone after it – but an internal, government conspiracy is another matter, and much more threatening, in both a political and physical sense. Who wants to go after the guys in their own organization who were able to murder the president? Not LBJ (who told this, in so many words, to John Kenneth Galbraith), not the Warren Commission, and not the liberals in the US government who have shown, over the years, how easily they can be intimidated and out-maneuvered.

  6. Arnaldo M Fernandez says:

    Ironically, Shenon’s piece “Meet the respectable JFK conspiracy theorists” would exclude him from the meeting. His criticism against WC is based on the debunked hypothesis about the Castro connection. Shenon even spun a yarn about Elena Garro de Paz twist party with Oswald in Mexico City as the occasion taken by Castro intelligence to recruit Oswald for killing Kennedy. Shenon is actually cleaning the WC cruel and shocking act of framing Oswald, despite what is known thanks to books like Inquest or Breach of Trust.

  7. Avinash says:

    Even John Kerry had expressed doubts about the WC a few months back.So did Clinton and Gore in the 1990’s.

    • And of course LBJ expressed similar doubts just after the Report came out. LBJ later went on to say that he has no doubt Oswald fired shots, but that others could well have been involved.

  8. Jerri kindig says:

    I have been reading a great book on facts associated with the Kennedy Assassination. It’s called When The Past Came Calling by Larry Kaplan. It’s captivating reading of things that I had never heard of, and things that surrounded the assassination and the aftermath. larryskaplan.com is his site. It’s really worth the read, so much information out there to find and educate ourselves with.

  9. Ramon F Herrera says:

    Logistic note (not for publication). The link above (“Ghosts of November”) is not well formed. It has an spurious right bracket at the end. This is the proper URL:

    http://jfk.hood.edu/Collection/Weisberg%20Subject%20Index%20Files/S%20Disk/Summers%20Anthony%20Official%20and%20Confidential/Item%2012.pdf

    De nada….

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

In seeking to expand the range of informed debate about the events of 1963 and its aftermath, JFKFacts.org welcomes comments that are factual, engaging, and civil. more

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

exam: The Most Effective 9L0-964 Online Exam 100% Pass With A High Score, Examcollection 642-382 Vce Software On Store, Provide Latest 646-573 Exam Dumps Pdf On Store, Most Accurate HMJ-100E Real Exam With Accurate Answers, Prepare for the HP3-C30 Test Exam With Low Price, Provide Discount HP0-A08 Braindump Will Be More Popular, Latest Updated 000-216 Test Software , 100% Pass Rate C2140-823 Dumps Is Updated Daily, Buy Discount P2070-043 Questions And Answers UP To 50% Off, Provide Latest HP0-Y52 Study Guides with PDF and VCE Engine, Ucertify 00M-651 Exam Paper Pdf With High Quality, Certleader CISM Latest Dumps Is Your Best Choice, 100% Pass Guarantee 70-567-CSHARP Test Prep Is The Best Material, Find Best 50-665 Practice Exam Questions with PDF and VCE Engine, Prepare for the 050-718 Test Answers , Passguide VCPC510 Certification Dumps Is The Best Material,

weight loss: weight loss meal replacement shakes quick weight loss boca raton loss weight for teens asian weight loss tea what is the best weight loss surgery weight loss measuring tape fda weight loss medication apex garcinia cambogia plus weight loss clinic charleston wv carnitine for weight loss weight loss meal prep shopping list how much vitamin d for weight loss maria weight loss low carb diet weight loss first week jillian weight loss pills review tanzeum weight loss weight loss pills containing ephedra losing weight pills walmart safe diet pills prescription 3 weeks postpartum weight loss mega t green tea diet pills diet pills at rite aid paleo diet menu for weight loss weight loss clinic michigan marine diet weight loss bike riding for weight loss does diet soda prevent weight loss true life weight loss pill weightloss subliminal messages for weight loss cancel garcinia cambogia physicians weight loss reviews

vape: pop naturals vape pen smok nord ceramic coil leather vape holster alien vapors kamikaze vape tank rda vape vape glass tank vapors ecig vapor lab ijoy avenger firmware update mini lava tube ecig smok tfv12 replacement v12 rba deck nhale ecig bes build for uwell crown rba elite vape juice priv8 brands vape juice turning dark in tank e juice recipe clones the vaping rabbit the alice nike vapor ultrafly pro mcs top pod vapes voopoo models nicotine vaporizer pens tpriv mod smok coils tfv4 wholesale vaping supplies vaporesso target 2 review uwell crown replaceing coils voopoo drag 2 hard mode prematurely taking ecig off charger voopoo drag or voopoo vape unregulated box mod

male enhancement: vitamins that increase sex drive making my cock bigger male enhancement pills that work how to make erection harder naturally gas station boner pills vigrx side effects natural enhancement pills blue star status review super hard pills for sale delta prime reviews mens delay pills penis size wikipedia penis rate sexual superfoods viagra vs cialis hardness are natural testosterone boosters safe viagra girl 2020 anxiety med over the counter buy online viagra nugenix review bodybuilding yohimbe liquid sexual dysfunction in men men haveing sex over the counter energy pills pre workout drink walmart penile exercise best sex blog over the counter testosterone monster test booster reviews nitroxin male enhancement how to make your cum shoot time difference in rome

cbd oil: what does cbd stand for pure substance definition wikipedia cbd thc difference health hemp where to buy cbd oil rochester ny cbd testing equipment cbd drip platinum how to use cbd oil vermont cbd oil for edema the body shop brisbane cbd cbd laws in indiana bodybuilding cbd oil what is what cbd oil arthritis free animal por accommodation cape town cbd image rx long beach ca cbd oil for sale chicago who we are can i buy cbd oil and take it home coury and buehler cbd oil safe for cats chiral centers practice where to buy cbd oil in bloomington il nutrax cbd oil made definition rimadyl and cbd oil the truth behind tranquility cbd oil from hemp is legal cbd oil perrysburg ohio will you test positive for weed from cbd oil system healer license key free