Slate dodges the JFK bullet

Slate’s David Greenberg is one of those historians who prefers to discuss JFK theories rather than deal with JFK  facts. In his recent Slate piece, The plot to link JFK’s death and Watergate, (republished from 2003), Greenberg has this to say:

Elaborate speculations about Kennedy’s murder had begun, of course, earlier—almost from the moment he was shot. Shock and grief, along with lingering mysteries surrounding the killing and the gunman, Lee Harvey Oswald, stoked doubt that a lowly maniac could really snuff out such an august leader. But what started as normal human disbelief evolved in the next decade into a conscious program of radical skepticism, especially among the ranks of the New Left.

Since the New Left is going on 50 years old, the contemporary relevance of this claim questionable. But normal human belief–not disbelief–points to the obvious: we  really don’t have a very convincing explanation of the causes of the JFK’s death, at least not one that convince most Americans.

So why don’t we leave elaborate speculations aside and deal with the  evidence. Some of this evidence was available to Greenber in 2003;  some of it has emerged since.

To wit:

Lots of cops at the Dallas crime scene acted as though a gunshot came from the front of the presidential motorcade.

So did the Dallas doctor, Robert McClelland, who examined Kennedy’s head wound from a distance of less than two feet for ten minutes before JFK expired.

Afterwords, a number of Washington insiders–including the slain president’s successor, widow and brother–privately rejected official theory of a “lone gunman.”

The story in 2015

And now,  a half century later, we find a disturbing cocoon of unwarranted secrecy stil. surrounds several thousand unseen JFK documents. Hundreds of pages of censored material concerns the secret oprations of  CIA personnel who:

1) were informed about accused assassin Lee Oswald’s travels, politics, and clashes with the law in the weeks before November 22, 1963 (Anne Goodpasture, David Phillips, Birch O’Neal); or

2) implicated themselves or others in the crime (Howard Hunt, David Morales, Tony Cuesta); or

3) are known to have participated in CIA assassination plots against other leaders whose politics they disliked  (William Harvey, David Phillips).

(For the  details, see my May 14 post,  7 JFK files the CIA still keeps secret.)

While Politico notes that the still-secret CIA documents, scheduled for release in 2017, may embarrass the Agency,  Slate recycles the pointless but comforting anecdote that some JFK assassination theorists somewhere once called themselves “Brussell sprouts” in honor of the late researcher Mae Brussell.

Such amusements are feeble and dated but condescending  JFK conspiracy theories is easer than coming to terms with the historical record.




  1. Allen Lowe says:

    Jeff, you are missing the most obvious and blatant flaw in GREENBERG’s theory – which is that anyone who is involved with or follows New Left and post-New Left politics knows that this side of the political spectrum almost completely rejects the idea of a conspiracy in the murder of JFK.

  2. David Talbot says:

    Exactly! What kind of a historian is Greenberg, to be completely ignorant of the history of the “New Left” in regards to the Kennedy assassination? Prominent voices of the Left — from Noam Chomsky to Howard Zinn to IF Stone — firmly rejected conspiracy theories about Dallas, even as the evidence piled up around them. I think they did so for largely ideological reasons — in the case of Chomsky and Zinn they mechanistically lumped JFK in with Cold War liberalism, seeing him as little different from the rest of the hawkish national security establishment of his day (a profound misreading of the bitter and growing split with the Kennedy administration over the Cold War) — or in the case of Stone and his ilk, they were so worried that the assassination would be pinned on the Soviet Union and/or Cuba, thereby precipitating a dangerous global conflict, that they quickly rallied around the Oswald as lone gunman theory, as patently weak as it was. In other words, the Left’s leading intellectuals became part of the cover-up — and Greenberg has it completely upside down.

  3. David Talbot says:

    PS Greenberg cites New Left activist/writer Carl Oglesby — who did indeed devote his life to understanding the deeper significance of the Kennedy assassination and its connections to the US power structure — as his prime example of the New Left’s sponsorship of conspiracy-think. But Oglesby — who deserves respect for his pioneering work in the field — was a New Left outlier when it came to Kennedy research. Besides a handful of people like Oglesby, the New Left hierarchy — particularly on the East Coast — toed the establishment line on Kennedy. It took maverick Left Coast publications like Warren Hinckle’s Ramparts magazine, to do serious JFK conspiracy research. Meanwhile, bastions of the East Coast left, like The Nation magazine, continue to publish lone gunman propagandists like Max Holland, who has been acclaimed by the CIA for his scholarship. East Coast power corridor bubble-think is a powerful force field, especially when it comes to the Kennedy assassinatoin, pulling in even bold intellectuals like Chomsky.

  4. Jeff says:

    Jeff – “Pentagon’s destruction of JFK Assassination Evidence (12-11-1977) AUDIO ONLY”

    It seems Mae Brussell (noted in your article) was a Washington Insider who reported on many JFK matters, as per the audio of her show within the link below.

    Is Mae’s information presented in the audio, factual? If so, would it help for the House Oversight Committee to know about these facts in regards to the JFK Act? I guess that’s an obvious question and answer.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

In seeking to expand the range of informed debate about the events of 1963 and its aftermath, welcomes comments that are factual, engaging, and civil. more

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

weight loss: garcinia cambogia weight loss vegetable juice weight loss gastric balloon weight loss probiotic help weight loss emu oil for weight loss best protein bars for weight loss martyn eaden weight loss amphetamine salts weight loss paul teutul jr weight loss quick weight loss menus is cheese good for weight loss weight loss food for men harwin weight loss clinic vegetarian weight loss program juice cleanse weight loss results best morning smoothies for weight loss stevie nicks weight loss best fiber supplement for weight loss frozen grapes weight loss is coke zero bad for weight loss slim fast for weight loss 30 day weight loss diet meal plan paleo secret to rapid weight loss pure extract garcinia weight loss in diabetes water challenge weight loss papaya shake for weight loss chrisette michele weight loss printable meal plan for weight loss fasted cardio for weight loss fitness tips for weight loss best bedtime snacks for weight loss phentermine weight loss pills uk nutrition plan for weight loss japanese pink diet pills raspberry ketones weight loss review white lightning diet pills review biblical weight loss plans kosher diet pills total body cleanse weight loss bbc news diet pills chinese herb diet pills safe quick weight loss diet grapes weight loss pregnancy diet for weight loss green smoothie weight loss ketogenic diet weight loss stories best time to take fat burners

cbd oil: vape pen with cbd oil new leaf naturals cbd oil doterra copaiba vs cbd oil cbd oil cured anxiety cbd curcumin certified cbd cbd oil gel capsules where can i buy cbd oil in vero beach florida buy cbd in ohio how much cbd oil is necessary to help with brain fresh thyme cbd oil reviews what for or for what is cbd federally legal 2019 top rated cbd oil 2018 western union adelaide cbd computer shops brisbane cbd cbd bath bomb near me does cbd test positive on drug tests unscheduled synonym mama ds cbd specturm phone number amazon massage oil maximum percocet dosage cbd tinture fatigue and irritability empty capsules cvs my oil business free shipping ablis cbd drink thc effect on liver drop by definition best oil for edibles golden harvest cbd abbvie levothyroxine cbd plus tahlequah pill bottles wholesale where to buy pure cbd oil drops revital u cbd sleep cbd vape juice effects can cbd oil relieve arthritis pain cbd oil cures cbd oil for sciatica dosage sunday cbd gummies ananda cbd oil side effects gummy bears having sex hemp oil vs cbd sleep new cbd oil should cbd oil be from hemp seed oil salad bar melbourne cbd

male enhancement: vitamins for male libido boys dick sexually depressed ingredients in ageless male guy on viagra buying performance enhancing drugs how to make your dick fatter maca root walgreens making penis hard how to correctly measure penis surgically enhanced penis just for men hair different looking penis male enhancement distributors average penis length us testosterone gel bodybuilding status testosterone booster reviews rhino 7 male enhancement is it safe red fortera reviews does vigrx plus work viagra for men cvs side effects of testosterone pills sex tape google drive death erection sex drive synonym zoloft erectile dysfunction whats good sex big tan dick tadalafil vs sildenafil g 25 pill best vitamins for erectile dysfunction congo sex terazosin cost pheromone body spray l arginine side effects anxiety dicks to big why hasnt my penis grown shoot big load loss of sensation in penis nitric oxide vitamin shoppe sex disorders black mamba pills do testicles produce testosterone male enhancement e liquid stamina pills amazon best vitamins for erectile dysfunction what is extenze plus best citrulline malate

vape: vape shop charlotte nc direct to lung vaping best vape pen for oil vapeworld review 1 gallon vape juice different vape batteries internal battery vape steam vapor cleaner vape box mods ebay vape rechargeable battery vape shelf best vape for chain vaping how many hits from a vape pen to get high rda and mod pax juul ecig voopoo vinci coil vape juice with nicotine australia atomizer cleaning melon milk crusher vape juice vapor iphone cases cheap top quality vape juice vape not working after coil change e cigarette stores in los angeles ecig bong dead rabbit v2 rda vapor mitigation system suorin air flavors pepsi flavored vape juice best e liquid tank 9 south vape dj vapes 18650 battery vape subox mini kangertech gypsy vape juice do vape pens have nicotine nike vapor carbon 2014 vape mod lightsaber dragon ball z vape mod uwell crown coils definition how to use alpine vape pen eaning uwell coils best rechargeable vape mod voopoo gene chip firmware designs voopoo vinci rba new voopoo drag 2 lancet respiratory medicine journal ecig voopoo n1 coil material uwell amulet vape

exam: Testking 9A0-306 Cert Guide On Sale, Certforall 640-864 Exam Materials With The Knowledge And Skills, Download 642-780 Test Questions For Download, Passeasy 1Y0-722 Practice Will Be More Popular, Best HP0-S42 Exam Materials Online Store, Exam-Labs HP0-490 Prep Guide Is What You Need To Take, Buy HP0-P21 Questions And Answers UP To 50% Off, Up To Date HP0-M92 Exam Dumps Pdf Is The Best Material, First-hand HP2-Z16 Sample Questions With High Quality, Prepare for the 000-598 Exam Topics Is The Best Material, The Most Effective HP2-B126 Exam Guide Is The Best Material, We Provide COG-622 Practice Exam Questions Sale, Pass4sure HP0-Y19 Exam Collection Latest Version PDF&VCE, Find Best CCBA Exam Paper For Download, Exambible JN0-321 Test Engine Is Updated Daily, Test-inside 070-562 Testing Latest Version PDF&VCE, Most Important MB7-226 Exam Are Based On The Real Exam, Offer 1Z0-485-CN Pdf Exam On Store, We Provide 1Z0-630 Exam Demo Is Your Best Choice, We Have PEGACBA001 Study Guide Book With New Discount, Topdump HP2-E40 Cert Exam With New Discount, Provide New STI-104 Test Questions Is What You Need To Take, Provide Latest ST0-083 Exam Questions And Answers Covers All Key Points, Helpful 70-503 Pdf Will Be More Popular,