Max Holland reinterprets the Zapruder film


“What more can possibly said about the Zapruder film?” asks historian Max Holland in this May 7 talk at the 6th Floor Museum in Dallas. His answer: the first gunshot was fired before Abraham Zapruder began filming. He argues that the shooting took place over 11 seconds, meaning Lee Oswald had plenty of time to fire the fatal shot.

The presentation begins at 4:25. (Click here to start with Holland).

Holland’s findings revise the conclusions of fellow “lone gunman” authors Gerald Posner, Dale Myers, Larry Sturdevant, and Vincent Bugliosi who contended that Oswald fired all three shots in 6-8 seconds.

To his credit, Holland does seek to grapple with two key problems of the lone gunman theory–how could Oswald get off three shots in that time frame, when many expert marksmen could not–and how to explain the missed shot that wounded bystander James Tague.

As for themany other problems with the lone gunman theory Holland dispatches them all by invoking what he calls  a “consensus” about the nature and origin of the gunshots. His consensus is a consensus of like-minded authors only, a rhetorical sleight of hand that obscures the fact there was and is no consensus about the origins of the gunfire.

There was no consensus among 216 Dealey Plaza eyewitnesses, nor among the many law enforcement officers on the scene, nor among the doctors who observed JFK’s wounds. One of the Dallas doctors who saw JFK’s head wound close up, Robert McClelland said it could have only been caused by a gunshot from the front of the motorcade.

Of such credible evidence Holland has nothing to say, which is perhaps the most interesting thing about his talk, that he seems to have given up engaging the evidence.

 

3 comments

  1. Arnaldo M. Fernandez says:

    The crazy notion of “eleven” instead of six seconds in Dallas is a Max Holland-Johan Rush joint venture written in 2007 for the History Channel’s web site and broadcasted in 2011 as The Lost Bullet for the National Geographic cable outlet: LHO would have fired and missed the first shot before Zapruder started filming, just after JFK limousine turned from Houston St. onto Elm.
    However, if LHO was ready to fire so early on Elm St., why wouldn’t he have fired an certain unfailing shot as the limousine was on Houston right below the sniper nest? And why did he miss?
    Holland argued the bullet firstly hit a traffic light, as if the shooter could have lined up the shot in disregard of that light and its metal pole.
    Anyway Holland’s lost bullet must be counted as the one hitting a curb about 400 feet away and raising the shard of concrete that hurt Jim Tague in the cheek. Since LHO allegedly used bullets coated in cooper and neither the curb nor the shards showed traces of it after forensic testing, Holland’s lost bullet ironically dismissed his hypothesis about LHO as the lone assassin.

  2. pat speer says:

    Max makes a number of mistakes in his presentation. At one point he even claims a witness saying the limousine was by a lamp post at the time of the first shot as support for his theory the limousine was just starting down Elm street at the time of the first shot, even though the video of this witness (Pierce Allman) shows him pointing down the street AWAY from the location Max is pushing.

    But Max is not alone in his avoidance of the unavoidable. When one reads through the witness statements it is clear there are a number of points that come up over and over again, and are indicative of what really happened. One of these is that the first of three shots heard by those around Kennedy…hit Kennedy. And another is that the last two shots (or sounds) were very close together, and suggestive of more than one shooter.

    As a footnote to this first conclusion–which the witnesses support by a score of 25-1, by last count–moreover, it should be pointed out that not one witness said a shot was fired, but that Kennedy paid it no never mind and resumed waving to the crowd.

    So, yes, while one studying the eyewitness statements might have trouble determining exactly what happened, one should have no trouble ruling out a number of scenarios that most definitely did not happen–as determined by an overwhelming consensus of the witnesses. And Max’s scenario is one of them. It did not happen. It’s pure moonshine, as daffy as anything cooked up in the conspiracy research community.

    And yet this completely unsupported theory/fantasy continues to find support in prominent newspapers, magazines, and television networks. This shows how very little the people working in these places know or understand about the assassination.

    So, at least in that light, Max and his wacky theory have provided us a service.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

In seeking to expand the range of informed debate about the events of 1963 and its aftermath, JFKFacts.org welcomes comments that are factual, engaging, and civil. more

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

exam: To Pass Your Exam 650-154 Exam Book On Our Store, Ucertify LOT-407 Certificate UP To 50% Off, Buy C9020-461 Ebook Pdf With The Knowledge And Skills, Examcollection 000-539 Dump Is The Best Material, Gocertify 00M-660 Real Exam Is What You Need To Take, Helpful M2010-665 Exam Demo Online, Experts Revised 74-344 Exam Book For Download, Most Reliable 920-132 Guide With 100% Pass Rate, Free 050-711 Simulation Questions Guaranteed Success, Useful GED-Mathemati-cal-Reasoning Braindump On Our Store, Real SZ0-250 Exam Vce with PDF and VCE Engine, Latest Updated 090-077 Certification Dumps , Sale Best TB0-107 Practice For Sale,

vape: micro g vape pen smok tfv8 baby beast tank vape royalty coupon reddit hohm tech batteries sigelei sobra best stealth vape pen vape shop staten island smok m2 temperature control vapor haus vandalia voopoo drag resin jade vicks vapor rub weight loss water absorption spectrum large vape juice dewberry cream vape juice can vaping cause lung problems vape coil building supplies vaporesso aurora play kit smok tfv4 seals black snow wolf 200w vape shop carbondale il vape cartridge diagram vapor cigarette explodes voopoo logos download braided vape coil voopoo drag mini fix the cace pax 2 vape pen

weight loss: lemon for weight loss blending for weight loss albolene weight loss before and after healthy weight loss solutions mexican weight loss pills diabetic injection for weight loss anna nicole weight loss teenagers weight loss stories hypothyroid medicine weight loss fat burning supplement soy weight loss weight loss mantras thirty ten weight loss for life is protein powder good for weight loss scientific weight loss tips armour thyroid 30 mg weight loss the best prescription weight loss pills apple benefits for weight loss hydroxy diet pills weight loss the office diet pills on line nofap weight loss diet pills that help burn fat the best otc diet pills quick weight loss center webster tx best natural diet pills

cbd oil: cbd in alabama cbd oil durango hemp oil and cbd oil motion rc p 38 cbd and anesthesia does cbd oil need to build up in your system cbd oil for ibd hemp cbd oil liposomes oleo cbd reviews vape shop branson missouri cbd oil telstra perth cbd reliant pediatric therapy services weed urban dictionary positive functions web info plus appalachian cbd ejuice flavor extracts que significa hot what does po mean medically cbd hemp oil topical cbd oil 2018 green wellness cbd walmart tomah cbd oil is cbd oil legal in nc 2019 cbd oil cost at k botanicals biotransformation in pharmacology

male enhancement: how to increase male stimulation sex with phimosis progesterone and libido what is the average erect penis size wifes sex drive supreme booster bodybuilding cock how to increase penis length naturally vitality for ed vasectomy erectile dysfunction best penis enhancement evil root pills for sale extenze results enhancement for men electric male sex toys viagra age top ten male enhancement pill t male testosterone boost review eye drop side effects sex at its best largest human penis j23 male enhancer nootropics reviews what is a good testosterone booster male enhancement uae black men jelqing