Ideological politics and the JFK conspiracy question

This 2014 Daily Caller piece about Jack Ruby, like the death of Richard Schweicker, reminds me that one of the lamest memes in the discussion of the causes of the assassination of President Kennedy is the claim that the question of conspiracy is actually a left-wing plot to undermine America.

The facts say otherwise.

Richard S. Schweiker

Sem Richard S. Schweiker, Warren Commission critic (Photo by Archive Photos/Getty Images)

Patrick Howley’s take on Ruby, whether you agree with it or not, bears no trace of left-wing heresies. Schweicker, who famously said “the Warren Report has collapsed like a house of cards,”  was no leftist. He was a moderate Republican who would have been Ronald Reagan’s running mate if Reagan had won the 1976 Republican presidential nomination.

Then there’s Roger Stone, famed hard-right political strategist, who blames  the crime on his bete noir LBJ (without much solid evidence in my view, but that’s another discussion). Is Stone the dupe of leftists out to malign America? I doubt it.

The most sophisticated variant of the argument comes from independent scholar Max Holland, who argues that popular suspicions of CIA involvement were wickedly ginned up by the Soviet KGB. Writing for the CIA’s historical journal in 2007, Holland argued that a 1967 story in a communist-influenced Italian newspaper was the work of  a KGB disinformation program, which influenced New Orleans District Attorney Jim Garrison, who then blamed the CIA for JFK’s death. Garrison, in turn, inspired Oliver Stone, whose hit movie “JFK” (it is said) misled America. Therefore America’s enemies used “the lie that the CIA was complicit in JFK’s death to unjustly traduce the agency.”

Roger Stone

Roger Stone, left-wing dupe?

It s a rickety argument undermined by many realities. In fact, the first JFK conspiracy scenario was published two days (not three years) after JFK’s assassination. The theory came from a CIA- (not KGB-) funded group and it blamed Fidel Castro, not the CIA. So any discussion of the influence of intelligence agencies on the JFK controversy ought  to address these facts. Holland and his editors at the CIA neglected to do so.

Garrison may have exploited conspiratorial suspicions when he launched his unsuccessful prosecution of CIA informant Clay Shaw, but he did not create them. Suspicions of conspiracy ran rampant from the start in Dallas itself, one of the most conservative cities in the country. A poll of Dallas residents in late November 1963 found 66 percent of respondents believing that there had been a plot to kill Kennedy. Those weren’t just  liberals talking.

And so it is 52 years later. Skepticism about the official story can be found across the political spectrum. That skepticism is founded not in any one ideology, but in a pattern of facts that still concern Americans, left, right, and center.


  1. Ronnie Wayne says:

    Mr. Speer, you have much more knowledge than I of the assassination overall. I defer to it but would like to point out regarding the right wingers included the Birchers, those who spat on LBJ and Lady Bird and Stevenson or who pushed or hit with sings, Harrison LLLafyette Hunt (not just the other Hunt, E Howard of CIA fame),
    Goldwater, LBJ……….

  2. pat speer says:

    It’s absolutely true that the first conspiracy-theorists were right-wingers. While many left-wing pundits and politicians decried the climate of hate in Dallas, which (perhaps unfairly) suggested right-wing involvement in the shooting, very few, if any, came right out and said this was a right-wing plot. Not so, Major General Thomas Lane. His 11-25-63 column on the shooting–written just after Ruby shot Oswald–came right out and said they were communists who were working together. Lane surmised that, as “the assassination of President Kennedy would jeopardize larger communist interests”, Oswald was most probably not shooting at Kennedy. He then asserts that”the assassin had orders to shoot Gov. Connally and that he continued to fire until he did so.” Lane then concludes: “In summary, the available information suggests that the communist underground directed the assassination of Gov. Connally; that Lee Harvey Oswald bungled the job and killed President Kennedy by mistake; and that Jack Ruby murdered Oswald to protect himself and the communist underground.”

    And this was not an anomaly. This kind of stuff was published for months, years even.

    • “And this was not an anomaly. This kind of stuff was published for months, years even.”~Pat Speer

      Yes, this was a full frontal modified limited hangout. “The commies did it meme” that LBJ hoisted upon Earl Warren to get him to chair his bogus committee. A great red herring ruse for the crucial first years after the Report was released.

  3. Gerald Campeau says:

    Its a fact that Richard Schweicker gave only 60 min to Boris Pash’s testimony and Church committee as whole gave less then 2 weeks to investigate Pash’s PB/7 role in Assassinations and Kidnapping’s and his job as Army Counter Intelligence Chief for USSR well LHO was in Soviet Union was totally ignored.
    HSCA as far as we know did not investigate Pash and Robert Ellis Jones testimony was given a pass to his Truthfulness about his carrier in Army and Armies investigation of LHO and its lies about Oswald’s ties with Cuba.

  4. Philip Zozzaro says:

    It is easy to paint someone with the brush of conspiracy. Your website has been even-handed with the skeptics of the Kennedy Assassination. Two of the major investigations into the assassination were hobbled by conflicts of interest of investigating parties. The Warren Commission relied on a lot of the evidence gathered by J Edgar Hoover’s FBI which was derelict in its duty to stop the assassination and only gave information that didnt reflect poorly on them. Allen Dulles ran cover for the CIA in any role they had. The HSCA was handicapped by infighting over head roles (Gonzalez Vs. Sprague), budgetary concerns and then you had the CIA liaison to the committee being George Joannides, who ran point on the further cover-up. The fingerpointing of left vs right just continues the smokescreen. A moment in history such as JFKs assassination needs to bring both sides together in finding truth.

  5. Ramon F Herrera says:

    Are we now allowed to mention the partisan aspect?

    The policy of JFKFacts on that category of posts is inconsistent at best.

  6. David Regan says:

    Castro and the Soviets immediately smelled a rat and saw through the plotters facade of setting up a Communist sympathizer as the lone assassin:

    “Now,” Fidel said, “they will have to find the assassin quickly, but very quickly, otherwise, you watch and see, I know them, they will try to put the blame on us for this thing.” The next word came through, in effect, that the assassin was a young man who was a member of the “Fair Play for Cuba Committee,” that he was an admirer of Fidel Castro. Fidel declared: “If they had had proof they would have said he was an agent, an accomplice, a hired killer. In saying simply that he is an admirer, this is just to try and make an association in people’s minds between the name of Castro and the emotion awakened by the assassination. This is a publicity method, a propaganda device.” — When Castro Heard the News, by Jean Daniel; 7-Dec-63

    6-22-99; During the meeting of the Presidents of Russia and the USA in Cologne, Boris Yeltsin presented Bill Clinton with a very valuable gift – a file of documents from Russian archives concerning the murder of President John F. Kennedy in 1963. Among them, was a startling letter dated 11-26-63 from Ambassador Gromyko to the Central Committee of the Communist Party of the Soviet Union (CPSU).

    Secret, Copy No 1

    Central Committee of the CPSU

    26th November 1963

    Must be returned to the general department of the Central Committee of the CPSU

    The American Press is spreading various slanderous allegations about some “connections” between Oswald and the Soviet Union and Cuba. Oswald, accused of assassinating the President of the USA J. Kennedy, was later killed under mysterious circumstances. Some representatives of the American press are trying to justify their insinuations referring to the fact that Oswald had been in the Soviet Union from October 1959 till June 1962.

    The Ministry of Foreign Affairs of the USSR and the KGB of the Council of Ministers of the USSR have prepared a statement for the Soviet press with the purpose of exposing these allegations of the American press. The draft for this statement was based on the fact that now, after Oswald has been killed himself, the real face of those circles who are responsible for the killing of President Kennedy, and who are now trying to cover their tracks, is more evident. The question of expediency of such publication requires special consideration taking into account subsequent development of the situation in connection with investigation of the circumstances of Kennedy’s assassination.

    If American authorities contact the Soviet Embassy in Washington with a request to supply them with some information regarding Oswald’s stay in the Soviet Union, they can be provided with a relevant reference document relating to it.

    The draft of the statement attached.

    Asking for your consideration.

    25 November 1963
    A. Gromyko
    No 03381 /GS
    V. Semichastni

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

In seeking to expand the range of informed debate about the events of 1963 and its aftermath, welcomes comments that are factual, engaging, and civil. more

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

exam: Prepare for the 9A0-091 Study Guide With Accurate Answers, Most Popular 650-377 Certification Latest Version PDF&VCE, Ucertify HIT-001 Test Engine With New Discount, Exam-Labs EX0-112 Exam Test With 100% Pass Rate, Most Important FN0-240 Latest Dumps Are Based On The Real Exam, To Pass Your Exam HP0-683 Study Guide Online Store, New Updated HP0-382 Pdf Exam With New Discount, Buy HP0-J51 Exam Paper Guaranteed Success, SelfTestEngine A2150-563 Exam Materials Are The Best Materials, Provide Discount 00M-638 Practice Exam With Accurate Answers, Provides Best ICDL-IT Vce Dumps For All Candidates From All Over The World, Sale 70-454 Real Exam Is Updated Daily, Money Back Guarantee 70-506 Guide Sale, Latest 070-177 Exam Demo On Sale, Experts Revised MB3-209 Exam Practice Pdf , Helpful 70-502-CSHARP Vce Dumps UP To 50% Off, Useful CX-310-302 Exam Engines Are Based On The Real Exam, Easily To Pass 1Z1-561 Cert Guide Latest Version PDF&VCE, Exambible 1Z0-024 Test Prep 100% Pass With A High Score, Download 050-RSAENVSF01 Questions Is The Best Material, Prep4sure 190-821 Cert Guide Online Store,

male enhancement: myrbetriq reviews how to increase penis width how to correct ed medication rash pictures best penis pills foods that enlarge penis guess my penis size ptx male enhancement dick best best supplements reddit hgh and penis growth best natural ed products supplements gnc viagra discount coupon blue pill men hd dick sticking out male enhancement and vicks vapor rub add hair app median penis size should viagra be taken with food what is the largest penis size pines enlargement pills penis buyutucu hap nugenix cost circumference of a penis sex candles amazon little blue pill c1 drive increaser arginine erectile dysfunction dose penis growth spell tree bark repair methods men hair growth pills peni definition natural ed solutions an erection of the penis is caused by bleeding from penis inflamed foreskin male sexual anxiety nugenix scam sleep apnea erectile dysfunction kangaroo male enhancement ebay grow your cock

vape: roccos vape lounge authenticate uwell crown vine vape wow inspira ecig coil vape shoes smok al85 coil change square battery vape j 118 e cigarette vapetasia blackberry lemonade blu e cig vs cigarette nike mercurial vapor flyknit ultra vape nic suck dic bauer vapor x 60 skates womens vapor glove 2 dna vape juice gold and black ecig with lion e cigarette battery near me usb passthrough vape best vaping mod vape place pico vaping online infant vapor rub vegetable glycerin walmart vape brothers how to blow smoke hearts vapor pens with no nicotine suorin vagon review ecig fall river stick vs bamboo ecig beat mods lost vape orion pod alien smok mod wont turn on best rebuildable rda t priv 3 firmware update tank electronic cigarette cheap e cig mod kits high pg vape juice uwell crown subtank coils tobacco nike vapor fly pro driver for sale uwell crown parallel coils vape pens harmful

weight loss: shark tank weight loss pill episode rush limbaugh weight loss proven weight loss supplements weight loss pills available in pakistan dr quinn weight loss best weight loss plan for me 6 week weight loss challenge 6 week weight loss program adipex for weight loss body wrap for weight loss america weight loss center mom weight loss before and after are egg yolks bad for weight loss cnn weight loss pill sparkling water weight loss diet pills in walmart best breakfast food for weight loss spark weight loss how to loss weight by diet maxzide 25 mg weight loss perimenopause and weight loss adipex diet pills order online chevy chase weight loss ginger benefits for weight loss weight loss meal plan men 5 pound weight loss before and after profile by sanford weight loss center quick weight loss port st lucie famous weight loss pills buy tapeworm diet pills online gardenia diet pills pure life keto pills reviews safe diet pills fda approved weight loss pills for bodybuilding quick weight loss tips for diabetics rewards for weight loss milestones quick weight loss plan reviews 21 day weight loss breakthrough recipes prescription diet pill phentermine accelerator boost diet pills keto lean pills reviews weight loss shakes diet

cbd oil: cbd products near me cbd and pain management ultra cell cbd chronic back pain meme kentucky farms cbd cbd scams medical marijuanas doctors pure cbd exchange cbd oil texas vape 5 cbd oil cbd oil for inflamation miracle cbd cbd age walmart vape pen cbd 350mah battery charger kit michaels naturopathic programs cbd oil cbd skin care private label how to take cbd oil under tongue reliva cbd cream 3 cbds of london cbd oil shoprite cbd oio cbd square cbd oil latest news cbd dose for depression cbd dosage for weight loss any person any study even naturals pure brazilian reviews would cbd oil interact with tacrolimus cap 1 mg apoptosis definition cbd oil cluster headaches sex how to do everything wiki psychopharmacology bulletin cbd 4 paws darwin cbd can you dilute cbd oil diabetes 101 can small fiber neuropathy cbd oil metronidazole gel cbd oil for dermatomyositis dr hemp