Historian needs to catch up on JFK scholarship

In today’s Washington Post, Larry Sabato responds to last week’s negative review of his book “The Kennedy Half-Century” by Rutgers historian David Greenberg. Greenberg’s peevish response about “assassination buffs” reveals what really irks him:

Sabato has an open mind about the causes of JFK’s assassination and the vast majority of Americans don’t buy Greenberg’s interpretation of November 22, 1963.

Larry Sabato

University of Virginia professor Larry Sabato

Greenberg seems both threatened by and disdainful of the new evidence that has emerged since Oliver Stone’s movie, which documents what Phil Shenon rightly calls “the secret history of the Kennedy assassination.”

The majority of sane American citizens who don’t believe the official theory of a lone gunman look for a more credible explanation in the historical record that the CIA and FBI and other government agencies long suppressed and that Stone’s movie forced into public view.

Oddly for a historian, Greenberg seem uninterested, if not ignorant, of what has been revealed about this secret history in recent years. He seems unaware of continuing CIA secrecy around certain JFK files.

Greenberg needs to catch up on recent JFK scholarship. As I noted in the Atlantic.com in 2010:

“Since 2000, five tenured academic historians have published books on JFK’s assassination. Four of the five concluded that a conspiracy was behind the 35th president’s murder.

“David Kaiser, a diplomatic historian at the Naval War College, and the author of a 2008 book, ‘The Road to Dallas: The Assassination of John F. Kennedy,’ concluded that Kennedy was killed in plot involving organized crime figures. Michael Kurtz of Southeastern Louisiana University came to a similar conclusion in his 2006 book, ‘The JFK Assassination Debates: Lone Gunman Versus Conspiracy.’

“In a 2005 book,’Breach of Trust: How the Warren Commission Failed the Nation and Why,’ Gerald McKnight of Hood College suggested that a high-level plot involving senior U.S. intelligence officials was probably responsible for the president’s death. In his 2003 book about the photographic evidence, ‘The Zapruder Film: Reframing JFK’s Assassination,’ David Wrone of the University of Wisconsin-Stevens Point argued that the famous amateur film footage of the assassination proves that Kennedy was hit by gunfire from two different directions. Wrone did not advocate a theory of who was responsible.

“A fifth historian, Robert Dallek of UCLA, wrote a 2003 biography of Kennedy, ‘An Unfinished Life: John F. Kennedy, 1917-1963.’ While not about the assassination as such, Dallek’s book embraced the Warren Commission’s lone-gunman finding, relying on Gerald Posner’s outdated 1994 anti-conspiratorial best-seller ‘Case Closed: Lee Harvey Oswald and the Assassination of JFK.'”

8 comments

  1. Photon says:

    What is so outdated about Posner’s book. The section debunking all of the “mysterious deaths” is reason alone to read it.

  2. CA says:

    From Wikpedia:

    Posner was the chief investigative reporter at the Daily Beast. Following the revelation that a number of Posner’s stories for the Beast contained portions plagiarized from articles in other publications, Posner resigned from the Beast.[24][29][30][31][32] According to Posner, the plagiarism was inadvertent and the result of the “compressed deadlines” of the Beast and confusing his assembled research with his own writing in the “master files” he assembled on each story. Allegations of plagiarism also surfaced concerning his latest book, Miami Babylon (October 2009).[33][34] Posner said the Miami Babylon plagiarism occurred because of a new system of “trailing endnotes”, because an individual he interviewed read one of the plagiarized sources and reiterated it during the interview, and because he mistook other people’s writing for his own after scanning source documents into a computer database.[35][36] The Miami New Times also found that Posner “seems to add, subtract, or misattribute quotes” and displayed a series of such “apparently altered or misattributed quotes”.[34][37] For all the examples shown, Posner cited a source article, where an examination of the source showed that the quote given in Posner’s writing was either substantially altered (e.g. words added), never said by the subject, misattributed, or used out of context.

  3. Joe w. Heyer says:

    We Were There – Dallas Doctors reply to recent survey about their
    memories of Dallas. Page xiii Dr. Ron Jones, Arlen Specter before
    his interview, “not interview any who say shots from front.”

  4. Nathaniel Heidenheimer says:

    Sabato may have an open mind about JFK’s assassination. His descriptions of JFK’s policies reveal a careerist mind that seems incapable of critically interrogating beltway narratives of the most important moments in the history of US National Security State.

    Sabato seems to have no grasp whatsoever of any of the more recent academic publications on JFK’s foreign policy. Too much of his book seems like it might have been written by David Halberstam and or Seymour Hersh around 1972, although Seymour needed to wait longer than that for more people to forget that he was a hawk on Vietnam and opposed Diem for Hawkish reasons (I mean in his first book on Vietnam, not the Best and The Brightest)

    Sabato’s book is so shallow and under-researched that he makes the perfect beltway aca-pundit for our Morning Joed Corporate World. He longs to get to discussions of style ASAP so Vietnam, nuclear first strikes, et al take a backseat in terms of his research. What a prigish,aggressively superficial Court Historian! No wonder his book got so much corporate air-wave.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

In seeking to expand the range of informed debate about the events of 1963 and its aftermath, JFKFacts.org welcomes comments that are factual, engaging, and civil. more

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

weight loss: juice cleanse weight loss tnt weight loss pills review cycling for weight loss guaranteed fast weight loss candace cameron bure weight loss weight loss visual eft tapping weight loss swimming workout for weight loss apple shape weight loss top rated diet pills that work realdose weight loss natural diet pills that work shot for weight loss true diet pills that work protein for women weight loss gotu kola weight loss fiber supplement weight loss fuel diet pills weight loss with probiotics bio pills to lose weight low carb high fat diet weight loss weight loss on paleo 30 day challenge egcg for weight loss weight loss challenge prize ideas soloslim diet pills weight loss surgery failure side effects diet pills loss weight fast exercise alibi diet pills long term weight loss statistics diet pills containing dmaa best workout pills all vegetable diet weight loss diet pills that work and are safe low carb diet weight loss plan joaquin phoenix weight loss miranda kerr weight loss diet lean shakes for weight loss weight supplements bpi weight loss keto factor pills reviews fast weight loss for men

vape: w vape pens nike vapor fly elite what is pg and vg vape mods tanks breathe vapor stick vap battery eluminate ecig ecig charleston address ecig watt chart vaporesso target kit vape e juice for sale uwell crown 4 mod kit e cigarette liquid vaporizer leaving ecig mod in car best sub ohm tank for flavor voopoo drag 2 batter ysize how long is e juice good for medical vape buy eliquid vapor shark e liquid review rafale tank review vape phoenix how to prime a sub ohm coil smok skyhook wont turn on smok wood mod kroma a with voopoo uforce leaky uwell crown tank aspire odyssey mini kit uwell crown harsh criss cross vape uwell rafael x manual mustang mods vape my uwell crown is leaking used mechanical mod drag 157w tc tcr box mod by voopoo review one stop smoke shop voopoo drag mini wont charge wasp vape pen voopoo squon tobacco liquid for e cigarette voopoo drag platinum blue blu cig e cigarette explodes

cbd oil: cbd effects on blood pressure what is cbd like the best cbd does cbd oil show up on a drug test texas cbd gummy recipe jamie richardson cbd oil shark tank cbd hemp plant spacing what id cbd is cbd oil psychoactive sativa cbd vape oil does cbd kill your high cbd coconut oil medterra coupon johnson and johnson cancer causing adelaide accommodation cbd cbd oil fat content is cbd legal in wv cbd and adhd research cbd 954 hawaiian dream cbd cbd usa grown is cbd vape legal does cbd oil help with colds how to use cbd oil with low dose naltroxene synonym shop cbd oil scam potential definition science cbd pharmacology valsartan dosage our reviews today urban dictionary corn how to use cbd for diabetes real estate management advisors llc coury and buehler snopes adhd smoking hemp for cbd cbd yerba mate cbd gummies reviews headaches cbd oil how to make cannabis oil for pain relief stors in ny that carry cbd oil emu 420 cbd oil

exam: Examcollection 9A0-150 Book Pdf With High Quality, Examcollection 646-671 Questions And Answers Pdf For Sale, Test-inside 646-985 Training Guide Online, 100% Real 1Y0-614 Material Pdf For Each Candidate, Reliable and Professional E20-820 Exam Cram Online Sale, Most Hottest EE0-511 Dumps Pass4sure with PDF and VCE Engine, Helpful HH0-330 Certification Material Is Updated Daily, Certleader ACSO-L2-PROC-02 Book Pdf Will Be More Popular, The Best HP2-H04 Brain Dumps On Store, Certshared 000-156 Pdf Download , Welcome To Buy C2070-583 Certification Braindumps , Best 070-548-CPLUSPLUS Book Pdf With High Quality, Best 070-121 Practice Exam Questions 100% Pass With A High Score, Buy Best 070-232 Test Software Online, ITexam-Answers MB3-409 Simulation Questions With 100% Pass Rate, Testkingdump MSC-321 Exam Dump Is Your Best Choice, Download Latest 1Z1-877 Vce Software with PDF and VCE Engine, Help To Pass 1Z1-023 Certification Answers with PDF and VCE Engine, Latest Release C9560-505 Certification Answers On Store, Find Best CPHQ Vce Download Is The Best Material, Pass the JN0-322 Study Guide Pdf With Accurate Answers,

male enhancement: how to get arouse a woman animal test supplements how to come sexually male enhancement leads stay hard pills over the counter penis skin stretching is cialis safe cocaine and erection penis pumps review penis tip red get my cock hard ultimate testo explosion for sale penis head enlargement good male enhancement pills ashwagandha sex drive legitimate penis enlargement pictures of male what size is a micro penis wiki penis fda approved sex pills cheapest viagra online vydox pills how long does viagra work rhino x male enhancement chewable viagra alpha muscle test booster benefits of l citrulline party pills reviews vitamin d deficiency and ed sexual power icd 10 code for erectile dysfunction online pharmacy free viagra samples uncircumsized penis picture penis numbness unerect penis foods that promote testosterone penis on fire alprostadil reviews where to get testosterone red lips male enhancement pills extenze energy shot viagra generico