Gladwell’s JFK theory revisited

In the Wall Street Journal Dorothy Rabinowitz reminds us that Malcolm Gladwell has endorsed the “derangement” of “the Secret Service Man done it” theory of President Kennedy’s assassination.

I think Gladwell will recant this dubious proposition if asked. I hope so.

The long-since refuted “Secret Service Man did it” theory is getting recycled on an upcoming REELZ cable channel and needs to be labelled non factual.

7 comments

  1. Mark Wright says:

    This show will be screen tonight in Australia, the man behind it was on Sydney radio and I rang into the host before he came on air to tell the listeners that this theory was disproved 20 years ago. The author and publisher were sued by SS Hickey at the time.

    Theories like these are a grab for cash.

  2. Hans Trayne says:

    Those who remember the shock waves the HSCA sent out to the global public about the CIA working with Mafia godfathers & their operatives during the JFK Presidency, followed by 1981’s imagination provoking ‘Blow Out’ movie (that insinuated Abraham Zapruder had foreknowledge of JFK’s violent & deadly ambush) probably remember Internet message board posters speculating that the SS Agents simply murdered JFK on Elm Street so as Zapruder could record their evil deed. This distrust evolved into the kinder, gentler theory that a careless SS agent accidentally did the deed while attempting to waste Lee Oswald; something incompetent Treasury guards would never admit to.

    This particular theory answers many questions for some people while antagonizing others. Those of us who collect original ambush visuals will keep an eye out for good versions of them in the latest documentaries released in 2013 while ignoring the snake oil bubbling in a pot on a stove top in the background of the video documentary.

  3. Malcolm Street says:

    Just watched the program after listening to the extended radio interview with Colin McLaren last week). The WSJ article says it’s a “docudrama” – it’s nothing of the sort – it’s a documentary that includes reconstructions that are obvious as such. That doesn’t give me much confidence in the rest of the article.

    I couldn’t give a rat’s posterior about Malcolm Gladwell. As McLaren said on the radio interview, not being American has given him the ability to look at the case (over four and a half years) with fewer preconceptions and just approach it as another cold case by going over the evidence at the time.

    The great strength of McLaren’s theory IMHO is that it fulfils the old journalistic maxim that if you can explain something by a stuff-up or a conspiracy, take the stuff-up every time. Yes, he says, there was a conspiracy involving the Secret Service, but it was a conspiracy to cover up their stuff-up.

    The issue of George Hickey suing over “Mortal Error” is covered in the program – apparently Hickey was sent (and received) pre-release copies of the book and did nothing, only suing after *two years* had elapsed. Why did he wait so long? It was settled out of court.

    I’m no expert on the JFK assassination and am willing to be persuaded of other theories, but this one ties up more knots than any I’ve come across without getting into tinfoil hat territory. Perhaps that’s the problem with it – there seems to be need for Americans to see a tragedy of such magnitude as the result of a conspiracy and the idea that it could be the result of a squalid stuff-up perhaps seems to diminish it.

  4. Photon says:

    At least he identifies a shooter, which no other conspiracy theory has done in 50 years.

    • Frankie Vegas says:

      Even if he is wrong and defaming this person he is naming. I personally find that shameful. It makes us all look bad.
      People don’t go naming shooters because that is wrong and awful and could lead to a defamation suit. I hope someone in Hickey’s family also feels this way. Disgusting!

      • Malcolm Street says:

        What he’s saying is that the shot that killed Kennedy came from an AR-15. The only person in the motorcase with an AR-15 was Hickey, and his location matched the ballistics. He’s not accusing Hickey of being an assassin – he sees it as a tragic accident that was brought about by a new weapon being put in the hands of someone who hadn’t been trained in it.

  5. Malcolm Street says:

    Colin McLaren’s radio interview can be found at http://www.abc.net.au/local/stories/2013/10/22/3874207.htm?&section=article&date=%28none%29. It’s one of a weekday series on ABC radio called Conversations, goes for over fifty minutes and covers material not in the TV program.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

In seeking to expand the range of informed debate about the events of 1963 and its aftermath, JFKFacts.org welcomes comments that are factual, engaging, and civil. more

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

cbd oil: 2500 mg cbd oil pure cbd isolate 25 mg cbd gummies oil science cvs cbd oil capsules buying oils online cbd oil san francisco cannabidiol fda approval cbd merchant account reviews alter ego fitness symmetry cbd oil tera pet list cbd versus hemp how much cbd oil for joint pain cbd gummies 500mg cbd oil news 2018 hippy chicks best brand of cbd tincture how to use cbd oil for joint pain cbd thc oil cartridge high mg cbd gummies cbd oil interaction leucovorin can u get high off cbd oil what is better hemp oil or cbd oil need information on taxi fare auckland airport to cbd neurology meme dr denboer cb2 ny medical used chronic pain managment afl merchandise store melbourne cbd cannabidiol at walmart best way to take cbd tincture kengle hat cbd oil bad for you cbd 30 mg gummies the kind pen cbd oil cbd oil dosage for arthritis pain gold cbd oil cbd oil dosage for infants cannabis mouth spray verified cbd oil for pain how long cbd oil last smart organics cbd hemp oil medical mary prices on cbd oil distance from preston to melbourne cbd how much cbd oil does an acre yeild vape hack client does homemade cbd oil have thc cbd oil usa cbd hemp oil critque pineberry cbd flower

weight loss: john goodman weight loss essential oil weight loss best weight loss exercises gemstones for weight loss funny weight loss quotes best weight loss methods non surgical weight loss malaysia diet pills diabetic weight loss diet detox smoothie diet for weight loss physicians weight loss center testosterone booster shots brat diet weight loss the best fast weight loss pills weight loss juices carb free diets quick weight loss hormone imbalance weight loss pill studies on weight loss pills best weight loss powder weight loss for children chum lee weight loss what foods are good for weight loss gabourey sidibe 2016 weight loss weight loss hynotherapy mirena removal and weight loss fast weight loss cleanse medshape weight loss clinic free loss program quick weight yogi tea detox review weight loss cheapest weight loss food delivery weight loss clinic flowood ms quick weight loss for diabetics 40 day weight loss challenge malabsorption weight loss 6 weeks weight loss perscription weight loss pill bill barnwell weight loss dhea for weight loss dr oz weight loss supplement list quick weight loss centers of america gastroenteritis weight loss diet pills in walmart soy weight loss dr now weight loss diet whitney weight loss weight loss winter recipes diet rx pills does accutane cause weight loss pure garcinia cambogia diet pills best workout equipment for weight loss magic pills to lose weight weight loss motivation book where can you buy keto pills supplements pills

vape: vape pen color settings wax pen coils dual battery vape mod e cigarette stores queens ground material vape sour patch vape juice idaho vape shops best small box mod nova vape pen smok big baby beast leaking cornbread pudding vape the hype blue slushee myle not hitting taco flavored vape juice mario carts cartridges voopoo mod manual pdf ecig holder for car smok amazon 802 ecig supply bellows falls best vape juice for cheap does vape juice stain clothes smok t priv case e cigarette pg vg vapor cigarette dangerous e cigarette exemption is menthol vapor bad for you vaping on plane vapor clouds arvada co phix website cottonwood vape nvape pen smok g priv 2 for sale dripper kits vape wax in vape juice flavor bad smok al85 kit review rba for beginners blue drop rda how to blow hearts lightsaber vape for sale lit vape cartridges kanger kbox nano be simple vape smok x xname reading wrong ohms bbtank vape uwell crown 2 coils wattage diy vape coils matte black uwell crown 3 how to make a lightbulb vape voopoo drag black frame churrios vape juice how to refill voopoo drag genechip update vape mods clouds voopoo tech security code check battery voopoo drag

male enhancement: prescription depression pills will viagra lower blood pressure oral medication how to avoid erection super viagra measures his cock blue stallion ed pills cures for ed triceratops drug paraphimosis pictures how big is a big cock iud sex drive how can you make your penis bigger big muscles small penis supplements that make you horny why would viagra not work 100 percent male real dick ageless male clinic reviews huge erect cock how to make natural viagra how to use a penus pump thick booty enhancement capsule how to measure dick girth tiger max how to grow your penis size viagra side effects are testosterone boosters safe generic of viagra free sex usa buy viagra online with prescription foods for penis growth erectile dysfunction issues alternatives to intercourse best way to increase blood flow cells of leydig ginkgo for ed smile care club reviews dallas cowboys sweats yohimbine erection roman hair loss diabetes viagra how to milk a penis whats wrong with pandora blue m 30 jelqing photo proof man in bed super male vitality ingredients herb names for girl cheap drugs bathmate hydro pump review jelqing exercise real male enhancement reviews herbal remedies for ed

exam: Pass4sure 650-302 Exam Questions For Each Candidate, New Updated 650-756 Cert Exam With 100% Pass Rate, Sale 642-618 Exam Dumps For Download, Test-inside M5050-716 Real Exam Questions UP To 50% Off, 100% Success Rate 1Y0-A25 Test Answers Are The Best Materials, Ucertify 1D0-442 Book Pdf With The Knowledge And Skills, Ucertify 220-601 Labs Online Sale, SelfTestEngine 220-802 Cert Exam With High Quality, Buy Discount HP0-J29 Exam Materials Online Store, Provide Latest HP0-M30 Test Engine Covers All Key Points, Passguide HP0-M95 Braindump Pdf With High Quality, The Best A2050-723 Test Pdf With 100% Pass Rate, Most Hottest C2070-991 Exam Questions And Answers 100% Pass With A High Score, Sale C2180-183 Exam Materials UP To 50% Off, Experts Revised LOT-983 Exam Questions On Store, Sale Best 000-617 Vce Files With New Discount, Helpful 000-817 Exam Preparation For Download, Latest Updated 00M-608 Braindump Pdf On Sale, Provides 000-154 Pdf Exam Guaranteed Success, Most Popular 70-667 Pdf Download with PDF and VCE Engine, Examcollection 70-583J Test Prep With New Discount, Exam-Labs 920-231 Real Exam Questions For Sale, Test-inside 50-691 Practice Exam On Our Store, Pass the 1Z1-351 Study Guide Book Online Shop, Prep4sure CX-310-084 Self Study Is Updated Daily, The Best HP2-Z09 Practice Test Pdf For All Candidates From All Over The World, Valid and updated CEH-001 Test Questions Are Based On The Real Exam,