CTKA disputes NOVA’s ‘Cold Case JFK’

Last year I appeared on a PBS Show “NOVA: Cold Case JFK.”

Dr. David Mantik published an extended critique of the show on the Citizens for Truth about the Kennedy Assassination Web site.

Josiah Thompson also complained about the show’s marshaling of evidence.

8 comments

  1. Frankie Vegas says:

    I can’t seem to view the video due to ‘rights restrictions’ in my region. I’m just going to assume it was fantastic.

    • Martin Hay says:

      Frankie,

      The show isn’t really worth watching but you can see it on youtube anyway:

      http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=z4VLmPxFyk8

      Just remember, it’s an hour of your life you’ll never get back.

      • Jonathan says:

        Martin Hay,

        Assuming arguendo C.E. 399 is not the bullet found by Daryl Tomlinson, who in your opinion switched C.E. 399 for the bullet Tomlinson found? James Rowley? Elmer Todd? Someone else?

        As I read the record, everyone says in effect, “Not me.”

        The only initials on C.E. 399 are the initials of the three FBI examiners. Neither Rowley’s nor Todd’s initials appear on C.E. 399; much less the initials of Daryl Tomlinson, O.P. Wright, or Richard Johnsen.

        The chain of custody for C.E. is flawed for evidentiary purposes. But I ask for your view of the truth as to provenance. Thanks.

        • Martin Hay says:

          Jonathan,

          I’m really not one for speculating so I’m not sure what to sayu. What we do know is that when Elmer Todd received the stretcher bullet in the White House he wrote the time he received it on the envelope it was in as 8:50 pm. But Robert Frazier, according his laboratory sheet, received CE399 at 7:30 pm. So clearly there were two bullets floating around that day.

          There are photographs that appear to show a sandy-haired FBI agent picking a bullet out of the grass in Dealey Plaza and putting it in his left pocket. Could it be that this was CE399 and the agent took it straight to Washington?

          Who knows.

  2. Pat Speer says:

    I also reviewed the program within my blog on the programs pumped out for the 50th, here:

    http://www.patspeer.com/the-onslaught

    The program is discussed in the November 11 and 13 entries. Enjoy.

  3. Neil says:

    Martin Hay and George Bailey also have some really good rebuttals of the dis-info on ‘Cold Case’

    George Bailey –
    http://oswaldsmother.blogspot.com/2013/11/lies-omissions-and-pbs-nova-cold-case.html

    Martin Hay –
    http://themysteriesofdealeyplaza.blogspot.com/2013/11/nova-cold-case-jfk-case-study-in-cherry.html

    • Jonathan says:

      Neil,

      I’ve read Martin Hay’s excellent essay, which deals to an extent with the ballistics of C.E. 399.

      For me, the clincher on C.E. 399, what would prevent it from being admitted as evidence at trial, is the complete lack of chain of custody prior to the time it was turned over to Robert Frazier of the FBI (and there’s even some fuzziness as to that time).

      Daryl Tomlinson found a bullet on a gurney at Parkland Hospital. There is no factual basis for believing it was JBC’s gurney (stretcher). Tomlinson later told Josiah Thompson that the bullet he found had a pointed tip, unlike C.E. 399, which has a round nose.

      From the record, C.E. 399 appears to materialize out of thin air.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

In seeking to expand the range of informed debate about the events of 1963 and its aftermath, JFKFacts.org welcomes comments that are factual, engaging, and civil. more

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

vape: formaldehyde in vape loadup vape supply top fill vape tanks vape menthol can you take vape juice on a plane anyone have the gold uwell crown gallery vape vapor for weed how to open vape tank nicotine river discount code 2017 vuse alto charger underground vapes flammable vapor sensor cause of vaping deaths juicys vapor 60 watt ecig what goes in ecig oil glycerin free vape juice subox e cigarette vape store jobs latest e cigarette model crown 7 ecig e cigarette brands 2013 components of a vape vaping coils explained ecig shop dublin euc universal coil vape store virginia beach best rebuildable rda smok nord pod gnome coils keep it 100 juice innokin t20 strong flavored vape juice okvm juice pulse 90w aspire triton vape tank cannabis vape pens uwell crown coils ni legs how to quit smoking with a vape how to take apart the uwell crown vodka in vape juice calliburn uwell vitamin vape pen voopoo too turquoise biggest rta voopoo uforce t1 replacement glass voopoo drag mini recommended settings

cbd oil: benefits of cbd oil for humans cbd oil keeps me awake at night sky cbd oil cassava root supplement cbd oil local warfarin and cbd oil cbd menthol cream does hemp oil work as well as cbd oil what is better cbd oil or hemp oil is cbd oil legit cbd oil utah 2017 cbd oil vending machine homemade cbd salve 50 thc 50 cbd how does cbd work for anxiety how does cbd oil help with pain cbd oil and ibuprofen interaction is cbd oil healthy cbd for pain research verge cbd kings of vapor cbd cbd 6 mm music shop melbourne cbd colitis espanol hemp oil near me how well do you know me questions compell definition dont do drugs pencil what is canabis oil what do you call people from los angeles term oil meaning cbd for joint and muscle pain pure recharge concentrate aspire elite kit use endow in a sentence cbd oil around me 19 pure sleep lazarus naturals vs barkley cbd oil cbd 6 mm max murillo wegmans cbd oil pain review cbd oil mankato hemp cbd oil utah giant eagle cbd oil what does bcd travel stand for buy cbd oil lakewood lamictal and cbd oil interaction

male enhancement: wellbutrin and libido best male enhancement pill for growth why is my sex drive so low male alpha hard does libido return after menopause natural cialis gnc viagra 50mg man who cant be moved myrbetriq how long to work penis feeling how long does viagra work for penis device best way to gain girth vitamin e for penis do natural testosterone boosters work what is extenze ageless male ingredients 5 htp sex drive where can i get sex long penis is nugenix good for you natural remedies for ed robot penis can you increase the size of your penis drive in movie sex average penis size for 15 when was viagra invented virectin dosage t 150 supplement rate penises pandora customer service number pictures of male enhancement pills exten zone 5000 intelligex pills pill with m 30 how to preform better in bed red spot on penile head harbs body shop unhealthy penis does yodi pills work testosterone beard extenze plus for sale vigrx plus pill sexual things to do to a guy maximum powerful male enhancement cause of morning erection male enhancement gel walmart how to get wife to open up sexually

exam: Helpful 9L0-611 Certification Material Is Updated Daily, To Pass Your Exam 642-732 Answers Online, Gocertify 700-501 Test Exam For All Candidates From All Over The World, Passeasy GB0-190CHINESE Exam Cram , Ucertify HP0-D09 Test Exam Online Store, High Success Rate HP3-X04 Study Guide Book with PDF and VCE Engine, Provides HP2-H18 Certification Braindumps On Sale, Prep4sure 000-732 Actual Questions Covers All Key Points, Most Popular 000-649 Practice Exam Questions Is What You Need To Take, High Success Rate C2010-539 Test Online Store, 50% OFF P2090-079 Exam Engines For Sale, Welcome To Buy RQAP-GCP Certificate With High Quality, To Pass Your Exam 70-576-VB Practice Exam Is What You Need To Take, Discount 070-296 Practice For Download, 100% Pass Guarantee FM0-308 Exam Test For Each Candidate, Sale Best 074-325J Preparation Materials Are Based On The Real Exam, New Release 074-679 Certificate Is What You Need To Take, 100% Pass Guaranteed or Full Refund 920-164 Prep Guide For Sale, 100% Pass Rate CX-310-052 Exam Book On Our Store, Buy Latest 1Z1-546 Training Guaranteed Success, Prepare for the ES0-004 Exam Prep For Download, Testking 050-SEPROSA-01 Vce And Pdf With The Knowledge And Skills, Buy ST0-116 New Questions For All Candidates From All Over The World, Gocertify 70-658 Practice Questions Online,

weight loss: rebel wilson weight loss diet pills that work fast for teenagers abnormal weight loss icd 10 weight loss pills doctors recommend milk thistle weight loss propylene weight loss pills weight loss review best diet for belly weight loss optavia weight loss reviews adiphene diet pills what is the best weight loss surgery best weight loss supplement gnc bible weight loss daily calories for weight loss weight loss colon cleansers weight loss clu green drink recipe for weight loss buy weight bone broth fast weight loss results revision weight loss surgery ninja smoothie recipes for weight loss diet pills and mood swings weight loss calories chart weightloss drugs lap band weight loss surgery fat burner pill topamax and weight loss dosage jalen rose weight loss jennifer lopez weight loss walmart does any diet pill work med team weight loss best natural diet for weight loss weight loss pill reviews weight loss clinic rancho cucamonga weight loss pills raspberry yogurt diet for weight loss plan vysera diet pills can eating once a day cause weight loss dr perricone diet pills tomato weight loss med diet pills gabourey sidibe 2017 weight loss can you take vitamins with diet pills iodine for weight loss do acai pills help you lose weight isagenix 30 day weight loss banana diet weight loss results texas weight loss center austin tx