Anthony Summers: ‘The absence of decent reporting on the facts of the case… shocked me’

Anthony Summers

Anthony Summers

Anthony Summers, biographer and former BBC correspondent, has been writing about JFK’s assassination for three decades for publications ranging from The Times of London to Vanity Fair. In my possibly biased opinion, I think his book, “Not In Your Lifetime,” is the best single volume on the JFK assassination and its confusing investigatory aftermath.

I sent him some questions by email and he responded as follows:

JFKFacts: You started reporting on the JFK story in the late 1970s. You were one of the first professional journalists to look deeply into the JFK assassination story. What did you discover?

Anthony Summers: At the time of the assassination occurred, I’d been a student at Oxford. I had reporting ambitions, and Dallas was almost the first real story I covered. I’d been working for a TV program during the vacations, and the program’s editor phoned within an hour of the assassination – it was early evening in the UK – to say he was gathering a team and chartering a plane to Texas. Could I drop everything and come?

I said “yes” of course – only for the editor’s secretary to call back later to say my trip was off, they’d “found someone with more experience.”

So much for me. Then, as time passed and as I watched the story unroll from afar, I cooled on the notion of ever working the story. First there was the unedifying sight of Mark Lane posturing on a BBC program, making a scene by walking out of the studio for no good reason. I’d been underwhelmed, moreover, by his book “Rush to Judgement.” The Jim Garrison caper in New Orleans, in the late 1960s, seemed more circus than serious investigation. (When I met the man years later – he asked, all cloak and dagger, that I should meet with him in a sauna. The disquieting experience did nothing to improve my opinion of Garrison.) Like many other journalists, I came to think that the Kennedy case was a quagmire in which reputations sunk without trace.

Only in the late 1970s, when word reached me that the House Assassinations Committee was heading towards a conspiracy finding, did I get drawn in. The BBC commissioned a television documentary, and I did most of the interviews. The first impression that left was not about evidence. It was the realization of how poorly the case had been covered by the media back in 1963 and 1964. Most media had covered the hell out of the “tragedy,” the assassination saga itself, then trusted the Warren Commission, which in turn appeared to have trusted the FBI and the CIA and other agencies on most things. The media had not hammered away at the story as they would years later, say, after Watergate. There had been no Woodward, no Bernstein.

Anthony Summers Not in Your LIfetime

Updated with new reporting

JFKFacts: Can you explain the reticence of American journalists to report on events leading to JFK’s assassination?

Summers: The absence of decent reporting on the facts of the case – not only in your country, but by and large worldwide – shocked me. Two factors, I think, explain why they flunked it. The first was the apparent certainty from the outset that things were cut and dried. Oswald had a gun. He had worked in a building from which shots appeared to have come, where a rifle and spent shells were found. Sufficient means and opportunity, then. Inconveniently, he had no known motive. He seemed, however, to be that catch-all Bad Person – a Leftist. Oswald’s death in his turn at the hands of Ruby jolted millions. Ruby came over, though, as a mere oddball. By the time the Warren Commission delivered its finding that Ruby had no real organized crime connection – a finding that was entirely false – most minds had closed.

The other factor in the media’s failure was generational. The assassination occurred in an America that was emerging from the Eisenhower era, an America sure of itself, comfortable with Authority. People tended to trust the government, had for generations been brainwashed into the notion that the FBI was super-reliable, not subject to influence from outside sources. The CIA, to the average man in the street, was pretty much a blank – an agency that dealt with foreign stuff. And with none other than the Chief Justice himself heading the Warren Commission, what cause was there for concern?

The best part of two decades later, then, I made my BBC documentary. Because I had gathered far more information than could be included in a TV program – and because I was ashamed of my profession’s failure back in 1963/4 – I decided to go on and do a book. By the time I was done with it, I had learned enough to think sane citizens had reason to doubt the Oswald-dunnit-alone-without-a-motive thesis.

JFKFacts: Why should our kids care who killed Kennedy?

Summers: It’s hard to answer without sounding like a schoolmaster. The hoary old Henry Ford quote “History is bunk” is inaccurate – if it’s truthful history. History matters. The assassination is now as far from us in time as was Lincoln’s murder to people alive in World War I, but the killing in Dallas still haunts America and the wider world. Even for young people, as I write in the Preface to this reworked edition of Not in Your Lifetime,” it seems still to have “a spectral presence” in our lives.

No other death of a single individual – one so young, embodying the hopes of a new generation – so traumatized an era. It stays with us, too, because Kennedy was killed at the height of the Cold War, at a time when nuclear war seemed a real and constant threat. Finally, it matters still because of a perception by millions – 70% of Americans, according to a poll this year – that the full truth as to what happened on 11/22/63 remains unknown. If that perception is correct, and if what remains unknown should turn out to indicate a person or persons other than Oswald – or in addition to Oswald – killed the President, justice was not done.

JFK in Ireland

JFK in Ireland (U.S. State Dept.)

JFKFacts: Do you think being Irish (or not being American) had any influence on your thinking about JFK’s assassination?

Summers: It’s certainly true that the Kennedy family is held to be special here in Ireland. His portrait still hung on the living room wall of many homes, next to that of the Pope, long after his death. Years ago, while sheltering from a torrential downpour in a boggy field on our Atlantic coast, I encountered an old farmer – dirt was engrained in his pores – who, one might have thought, had never mastered reading in his life. As the sideways rain continued, however, I gathered that this was a well-read man who received the Boston Globe on a regular basis, who knew a vast amount about the Kennedy presidency, and was a fount of knowledge on what – to him – had been the “world catastrophe” of the assassination. He had detailed knowledge that surpassed, I dare say, that of most ordinary Americans. This year, because it is the 50th anniversary, a large platoon of Kennedys have made the pilgrimage to the Kennedy home place near New Ross – not far from my home – and been welcomed on a national scale.

That said, to answer your question, the Irishness of John F. has not affected my thinking about the assassination. It is worth reflecting, though, given our national addiction to music, poetry, and theatre, that this was a man who had a instinctive feeling for Alan Seeger’s poem about having “a rendezvous with Death.” This was, too, a man who – hours before his death occurred – crouched down in his hotel suite and mimed how an assassin with a rifle might take aim at him. (That incident is evidence of a sort – Kennedy was apparently aware, as was his Secret Service detail, that his life was more than usually under threat at that time.)

Carlos Marcello

Carlos Marcello

JFKFacts: In Not in your Lifetime, you track down the FBI men who oversaw the surveillance of New Orleans crime boss Carlos Marcello in the 1980s when he allegedly spoke about his role in JFK’s assassination. What’s your bottom line about the involvement of organized crime figures in the assassination?

Summers: My bottom line on the Mafia is what any sensible bottom line has to be on the whole damn thing. This is, as the lawyers say – or used to say – a case where the verdict is – non liquet – “not clear”. More simply put, there’s smoke but no fire – nothing that’s provable guilt.

Marcello, whom you mention, was the Sicilian mafioso who at the time controlled organized crime in New Orleans and the U.S. Southeast. The other principal Mafia name often linked to the case is that of Santo Trafficante, who ran Florida. Each man had ample motive to kill Kennedy – the Kennedy administration was pursuing the Mafia as never before, hounding some of them out of the country. JFK’s brother, the Attorney General, had at one point had Marcello deported – though he managed to return. Snippets of information suggest both men spoke in advance of JFK’s coming death – in ways that indicated they had foreknowledge.

There’s more. Oswald was born in New Orleans, and his mother and her family had links to organized crime. In the summer of 1963, when Oswald was arrested following a fracas involving anti-Castro exiles – bail was arranged by an associate of one of Marcello’s henchmen. As or more important, for me, is the fact that – time and again – figures who featured in the case had links to Trafficante.

I don’t have much time, however, for claims that either mob boss admitted to a role in the assassination before they died. I explain why carefully in the book. As to allegations that Marcello may have made an admission in prison, the burden of information – including what former FBI employees say today (in this matter they all come over as stand-up, credible guys) – does not confirm it. Marcello may, moreover, have been senile by the time he allegedly made such comments. The supposed Trafficante admission, virtually on the eve of his death, doesn’t have legs either. At the time and place he is supposed to have made the admission, he was somewhere else.

JFKFacts: In the new edition of “Not in Your Lifetime,” you report that a prisoner in a Cuban jail in 1966 told a fellow prisoner that a man they both knew named Herminio Díaz, had been involved in the assassination. Are you saying that Díaz was shooting from behind the stockade fence on the grassy knoll?

Summers: No, I’m not, and that is not what I have written in “Not in Your Lifetime.” On this as on other matters – and especially because in this instance the possible implications are sensational – I have tried to record the development exactly as it occurred.

In 2007, former Assassinations Committee chief counsel Robert Blakey told me of a call he had received from a Cuban exile in his eighties living in Florida – a man who said he wanted to get something off his chest before he died. Having talked with the man on a lengthy conference call, Blakey and I thought he sounded potentially credible. We flew to Florida and interviewed him over two days.

What the witness said, in essence, was about the closest friend of his youth, Herminio Díaz. While working in a Castro prison infirmary in 1966, he told us, he had given treatments to a much celebrated anti-Castro fighter named Tony Cuesta. Cuesta, terribly injured and traumatized, mentioned that Díaz had spoken with him of his “participation” in the JFK assassination. That’s the kernel of the account, which has its strengths and weaknesses. The suggestion that Díaz was involved has been made before. Now, however, it is evident that he ticks several boxes. He had, the record shows, previously committed one political assassination and attempted others. He was a marksman, expert in the use of both rifle and pistol. He had worked for Mafia boss Trafficante. He was deep into the Cuban exile fight against Castro – and many in that movement saw JFK as a traitor. He was in the U.S. in 1963.

Former chief counsel Blakey and I agree that this is a persuasive lead that points more firmly to the possibility that Herminio Díaz had a role in the Kennedy assassination. None of the handful of people previously named as allegedly having taken part have had the “qualifications” Díaz had. I did a videotape interview with the witness and – should the TV networks wake up between now and the anniversary – the tape will be aired in the coming weeks. Whether today’s media is really interested in authentic reporting on the case, however, is another matter. Perhaps nothing has changed since 1963.

JFKFacts: When your JFK book first came out in 1980, its title was “Conspiracy.” In later editions, it has been “Not in Your Lifetime.” Why?

Summers: It was much against my will that the book was first issued as “Conspiracy.” My then publisher was addicted to one-word titles and thought that title timely, in tune with the House Assassinations Committee’s finding of probable conspiracy. I thought it would mean I’d be branded a “conspiracy theorist,” the last thing I needed. Mercifully, however, the book was treated as sensible and revelatory and praised across the board. Even by the New York Times, which infamously has rarely given a serious hearing to the very notion that Kennedy may have been killed as the result of a conspiracy.

Why did I pick “Not in Your Lifetime as the new title? Because Chief Justice Warren, asked whether his Commission’s documentation would be released, replied that some records – notably material that came under the rubric of national security – would not be released in the lifetime of his audience. Fifty years, however, have passed since the assassination. Why, if President Kennedy was killed by a lone gunman, are thousands of documents still withheld in 2013?


What is the government still hiding?

 “5 Decades Later Some JFK FIles Still Sealed” (Associated Press, Aug.. 18. 2013)

“Justice Dept. denies CIA officer was honored for coverup” (JFK Facts,Dec. 17, 2012)

“Court uphold public benefit of disclsoure about CIA officer in JFK story” (JFK Facts, June 19, 2013)

“CIA Still Cagey About Oswald Mystery” (New York Times, October 17, 2009)

“Morley v. CIA: Why I sued the CIA for JFK assassination records” (JFK Facts, Feb. 23, 2013)


  1. Tom Huston says:

    Tony’s book is one of the best out there in my humble opinion. He does not jump to conclusions but lays the facts out for the reader to absorb and form their own conclusions, excellent read.

    • mitchum22 says:

      Translation: Summers doesn’t have the professional guts — or the wisdom — to choose a narrative.

      The last thing we need 50 years later is he said/she said. As the great Martin Schotz wrote, this a FALSE mystery. There is no mystery:

      • larrywheeler says:

        How about Garrison’s book -On the Trail of the Assassins? Or Mark Lane book Rush to Judgement when he went to Dallas in 1964? Or Fonzi’s book the Last Investigation when he worked as an investigator for the Assassinations Committee? Perhaps Posner’s Case Closed shows real guts?

  2. Alan Dale says:

    Excellent interview. I believe it is significant that Mr. Summers chose to conclude his 1998 edition of Not In Your Lifetime with an entire chapter (Postscript: Oswald’s Cuban Capers) contributed by Dr. John Newman.

    There have been some important developments since 1998. Dr. Newman is currently working on what he intends to be his final investigation into President Kennedy’s assassination to be published in three volumes.

    Wilderness of Mirrors by David C. Martin; Deep Politics and the Death of JFK, and Deep Politics II by Peter Dale Scott; JFK and Vietnam, and Oswald and the CIA (2008 ed.) by John M. Newman; Our Man In Mexico: Winston Scott and the Hidden History of the CIA by Jefferson Morley; Enemy of the Truth: Myths Forensics and the Kennedy Assassination by Sherry P. Fiester; State Secret: Wiretapping in Mexico City, Double Agents, and the Framing of Lee Oswald by Bill Simpich. I consider each to be of significance and value.

    • Alan Dale says:

      ^ I would like to amend my recommendations to include Larry Hancock’s Nexus: The CIA and Political Assassination, an exceptionally well written historical study of how political assassination evolved within the Central Intelligence Agency.

  3. Chris Kade says:

    Thank you for an excellent series of questions of Anthony Summers. I have always been impressed by his seriousness, fairness and evenhandedness. His book is indeed one of the best, if not the best, on the JFK assassination.

  4. mitchum22 says:

    Oh, gee whiz. Mark Lane was a charlatan. Jim Garrison was a paranoid flake. And the MOB maybe did it. ‘Though probably not. . . And gosh darn those CONSPIRACY THEORISTS.

    There is no way the Summers book is superior to the work of Douglass, Gaeton Fonzi, David Talbot, Sylvia Meagher, Peter Dale Scott, Melanson’s “Spy Saga,” DiEugenio or Gerald McKnight. Not a chance.

    • Robert Harper says:

      Ditto on this. As good as Summers interview is, he didn’t have to take a swipe at Lane or Garrison – each of whom took enormous risks to his reputation to stand out and speak to power.

      • Jeff Pascal says:

        I agree there Robert, however Summers has certainly done much more than his share in bringing a fair accounting of President Kennedy’s murder to America and Europe.

        • Jeff Pascal says:

          Regarding John Newman, I have the highest regard and would like to see him not self publish, and have 500 pages tops. Both Doug Horne’s Inside The ARRB Volumes at 1800 pages, and John Armstrong Harvey And Lee at a 1000, had a lot of unique, potentially very explosive material, but they were way too long. If each had been cut to around 500 pages, meat and potatoes, no Oswald in the doorway, or Greer shooting JFK nonsense for example, that even with a small publisher I think both books would have had much more impact.

      • larrywheeler says:

        I agree. Why tear down another author to move the one you like best in the pecking order? I say gratis to all the researchers and authors who have moved the case forward. I have been moved to study this case forward by Lane, Garrison, Summers, and even those who I disagreed with.

  5. As for expert witness testimony, I’ll take these guys over lawyers or Fibbees.

    “The reason I knew that Oswald could not have done it, was because I could not have done it,” said former US Marine sniper, Craig Roberts, author of Kill Zone: A Sniper Looks at Dealey Plaza. “I walked away from the window in disgust. I had seen all I needed to know that Oswald could not have been the lone shooter.”

    But Roberts, a retired police investigator, wanted to know what did happen. Not content to dismiss the improbable feat, he delved into the crime from every angle.

    “First, I analyzed the scene as a sniper . . . I looked at the engagement angles. It was entirely wrong. ‘Here, from what I could see, three problems arose that would influence my shots. First, the target was moving away at a drastic angle to the right from the window, meaning that I would have to position my body to compete with the wall and a set of vertical water pipes . . . This would be extremely difficult for a right-handed shooter. Second, I would have to be ready to fire exactly when the target emerged past some tree branches that obscured the kill zone. Finally, I would have to deal with two factors at the same time; the curve of the street and the high-to-low angle law of physics Oswald would not have known.”

  6. A Sniper Looks at Dealey Plaza (Continued)

    Not content with his own critical appraisal, Roberts turned to another, equally knowledgeable shooter. “According to my friend, Gunnery Sergeant Carlos Hathcock, the former senior instructor for the US Marine Corps Sniper Instructor School at Quantico, Virginia, it could not be done as described by the FBI investigators.”

    “Let me tell you what we did at Quantico,” Hathcock recalls. “We reconstructed the whole thing: the angle, the range, the moving target, the time limit, the obstacles, everything. I don’t know how many times we tried it, but we couldn’t duplicate what the Warren Commission said Oswald did. Now if I can’t do it, how in the world could a guy who was a non-qual on the rifle range and later only qualified ‘marksman’ do it?”

    “The most dangerous man to any government is the man who is able to think things out… without regard to the prevailing superstitions and taboos. Almost inevitably he comes to the conclusion that the government he lives under is dishonest, insane, intolerable.” – H. L. Mencken

  7. Brian LeCloux says:

    For a revealing look into Anthony Summers’ methods, read his correspondence with Harold Weisberg at the Weisberg Digital Archive:

  8. r b miller says:

    I am not going to argue with Gunny Carlos Hathcock about sniping!

  9. David Regan says:

    The Cuban assassin with a deadly secret: ‘I shot JFK’ | via @Telegraph

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

In seeking to expand the range of informed debate about the events of 1963 and its aftermath, welcomes comments that are factual, engaging, and civil. more

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

weight loss: diarrhea weight loss chicken for weight loss big boy weight loss tamela mann weight loss 2016 gabi garcia weight loss belly fat diet pills review tanisha thomas weight loss surgery non dairy weight loss shakes medi weight loss login cellucor super hd weight loss results walk for weight loss success stories tru diet pills mushrooms for weight loss herbalife weight loss pills unintentional weight loss cancer when should you take keto diet pills heart rate for weight loss chart honey boo boo weight loss pics sparkling water weight loss colonics and weight loss non stimulant weight loss pills best home gym equipment for weight loss electrotherapy weight loss hyperdrive diet pills hormonal imbalance and weight loss didrex vs phentermine supernatural weight loss prayer rice diet weight loss results indian salad recipes for weight loss getting back on track with weight loss low carb pregnancy weight loss 5 month weight loss support groups for weight loss how many reps for weight loss otc weight loss pills fda approved weight loss nutritionist near me the very best weight loss pills water pills for weight loss cvs catalyst diet pills weight loss method diet pills gnc reviews meghan linsey weight loss recommended diet pills by doctors natural weight loss diet pills hcg ultra diet pills 100 pound weight loss before and after quick weight loss canton ga does amitriptyline cause weight loss quick weight loss home program quick weight loss miami fl sacred heart diet weight loss shaq weight loss leslie sansone weight loss diet weight loss drug contrave exercise diet plan weight loss weight loss coffee pills dr oz burn garcinia maxi weight loss pills keto cleanse pills vitamin b12 shots for weight loss

male enhancement: supplements for low libido smooth dick male arousal pills how much is 100mg strongest ed pill laxogenin benefits for your ed only gnc erectile dysfunction pills how often can you take sildenafil stretch pumps 100 mg viagra effects masturbation and ed what is levitra used for prime labs testosterone booster how do penis pumps work cialis otc girls with big penises all natural supplements penis enhancment pills vidalista reviews average penis flaccid cheapest viagra grow penis fast finasteride price girls who like big penis otc premature ejaculation 7 pound penis what to take for ed testosterone over the counter average size man penis black male pictures medical term for sex new viagra commercial actress name how to get penis longer blue drug pills blue diamond pill 100 on both sides horny goat weed benefits vigrx plus walgreens how to get horny men silicone injections penis cholesterol is quizlet viagra and ejaculation erect men pics how to do sex rogaine cost g n c male enhancement formula focus scam problem with erectile dysfunction mens with big dicks average penis legnth does sex boost testosterone increase penis sensitivity mulondo herb do steroids make your penis bigger indian horny sex finasteride wiki red spots on my penis head total revenue quizlet zinc finger protein testerone booster

cbd oil: cbd daily reviews cannabis pictures cbd formula beach club gulf shores palmetto cbd oil cannabis oil for copd cbd rubs forms of were cbd smoke shop near me cbd oil for carpal tunnel syndrome cbd benzo withdrawal cbd pure what is cbd mean best cbd online siskiyou sungrown pur 7 cbd oil dosage best cbd oil reviews 2019 hemp oil properties cbd oil for fatty liver is cbd oil topical muscle relaxant cbd oil on shark tank define well meaning pyoor cbd sex spray for long sex how to use cbd private castle what type of cbd oil to buy cbd oil during labor cbd and lupus cbd isolate price best cbd oil for fibroids adelaide cbd jobs cbd oil in houston 7 eleven denver jetts gym brisbane cbd doterra login page thc and blood pressure charlottes web hemp oil amazon cvs lake forest il does cannabis help you sleep cannabis cure all jon johnson photography cbd oil what to look for cbd oil and obesity benefit of cbd oil places to buy cbd oil another word for intoxicating pinapple cbd oil what cbd oil is right for me does cbd oil cause depression is it ok to take hemp oil with blood thinner simple explanation of cbd oil gorilla glue cbd oil is it legal to buy cbd oil in the us cbd drink mix vape shop with cbd oil in georgia cbd facial products can cbd oil help someone with cirrhosis of the liver insomniac water bottle webmd cbd oil dosage is marijuana cbd oil legal in az without a medical card

vape: federal vape ban smok priv v8 not working highest wattage vape wall vapor barriers where to buy vape coils premium e cigarette coupons 1100mah vape battery aspire bvc atomizer vape strings mr vapor disposable can u vape cbd oil juul vape pen starter kit g class vape uwell crown 3 coils spec check atomizer smok species 230w mod uncle junks ejuice vapor shark e cigarette reviews life is but a vapor bible verse parts of vape mod mamasan vape juice rebuildable dripping atomizer banzai vape juice atom bomb vape juice awesome vape juice g priv 2 kit hemp oil e cigarette new study on vaping e cigarette joyetech vaping causes acne is vaping cool smok vape novo vaping causes cervical cancer longest lasting sub ohm coils low nicotine e juice vaping stores in nj vape complete kids drinking e cigarette how often should i change my coil avid vape asmodus lustro 200w tc box mod cheap box mods for sale wismec reuleaux rx200 price ecig protank chainsmoker box mod aspire cleito exo drip tip just fog minifit boulder pods smok tfv4 smok alien baby beast low wattage uwell crown coils k box vape uwell crown forums pink box vape uwell crown ss coil temperature curve ego vapor cant unscrew crown uwell dual rda vape voopoo drag not firing healthy vapes

exam: Provide New AND-401 Test Answers With New Discount, Most Popular 650-127 Vce Download On Store, The Most Effective 1Y0-350 Dumps Will Be More Popular, Easily To Pass CS0-005 Training Are Based On The Real Exam, 100% Pass Guaranteed or Full Refund CATV612X-MEK Self Study On Our Store, High Pass Rate E20-870 Practice Guaranteed Success, 50% OFF 101 Exam Collection Is The Best Material, Exam-Labs HP0-281 Exam Vce Covers All Key Points, Examcollection ACSO-PROG-02 Simulation Questions with PDF and VCE Engine, Find Best HP2-Z31 Exam Paper Online, Download Latest 000-M42 Training Guide Online Sale, Money Back Guarantee 000-M63 Test Exam Is Updated Daily, Pass the CISSP Ebook With Low Price, High Pass Rate ZJN0-130 Actual Test Online, 100% Pass 70-443GB2312 Actual Questions UP To 50% Off, SelfTestEngine 070-551-VB Test Answers With 100% Pass Rate, Ucertify 70-549-CSHARP Real Exam Covers All Key Points, Passeasy 70-553-CSHARP Vce Software For Sale, Up To Date 070-512 Book For All Candidates From All Over The World, Certleader 070-625 Vce With New Discount, Test-inside MB3-409 Practice Test Online Sale, High Success Rate 920-352 Exam Collection With The Knowledge And Skills, Real 1Z0-593 Vce Software On Sale, Find Best HP2-K03 Study Material For Each Candidate, Most Accurate 090-601 Practise Questions On Our Store, 50% OFF 156-708-70 Pdf Exam UP To 50% Off, The Most Recommended 1Z0-462 Exam with PDF and VCE Engine, Prep4sure VCS-273 Exam Demo 100% Pass With A High Score, Find Best HP2-B116 Vce Software Is Your Best Choice, Latest Upload C9560-568 Actual Exam Online Sale,